Posts

It takes TALENT to be as bad at writing as the writers for the MLP IDW comics are.

@RogueBadnik
Also didn’t end. 2019 reboot was just the beginning.

@Phoenixflambe
I guess rebooting the TF comics didnt end well, uh?

@Kiryu-Chan
We shall wait and see. But I suppose Chrysalis being released is a cliffhanger no more and maybe they’ll get the redemption the show didn’t give which would ironically make the infamous ‘Fix’ canon and finally use Grogar for real this time. Since I’m a enjoyer of comics, I suppose additional things they could do is to build up more on those comic exclusive characters seeing that JW or not, they have little character and are easily forgettable. That or they only can make g5 comics.

I already said nay. MLP’s Best comics in the last few years were the Transformers crossovers, and they’re losing that license. Otherwise a lot of their comics have been incredibly spotty, with very poor direction and writing, and I don’t see that improving under IDW any time soon

Also the way they say “ditches” like they’re proud that they’re losing those licenses is a really dumbass take

Soooo….

Yay or Nay?

A lot of people here and EQD are apparently Nay.

@Background Pony #899F
I’m not even positive that there’s any proof the IP ownership has been replaced just because Image comics take over boy franchises like Transformers and GI Joe. I do remember they published Evil Dead.

So, question:
Since it seems Image might replace IDW (https://bleedingcool.com/comics/image-comics-the-new-publishers-of-transformers-and-gi-joe/), do you think Generations might be a final hurrah or will there be another miniseries?

@Background Pony #A464
Friendship in layman’s term. But in FIM consisted of Magic, Laughter, Honesty, Kindness, Loyalty and Generosity.

I do suppose the elements of Love do glow a familiar colour. But me being dumb, I’ve no clue on their correlation to Harmony.

@Phoenixflambe
That’s a good question, though the bigger question is, What’s Harmkny?

So regarding the pre-ornithian stories, what are the actual values and elements in place of Harmony? Since there’s Family, History and Purpose, it’s not exactly Harmony with what it already is represented by.

And asking the reverse for my compilation image, what element of love corresponds with Harmkny’s?

Yes.

@Anon-a-Miss
And was the one who first thought something was wrong with Accord and console Celestia of the situation.

@CORDZ2000
Yeah but that was years ago, are you telling me they had cold feet for years on showing or having a plot about her or going on an adventure with the others?

@Phoenixflambe
That’s a good point, too.

@Background Pony #114F
One of the reasons. That and she was quite unpopular cause her flaws outshine her pros.

@Anon-a-Miss
Fluttershy was brainwashed so she couldn’t anyway and honestly would Accord even feel more bad than Discord knowing that one, he brainwashed her like she was nothing to him and two, if Accord even had empathy or feelings to begin with. Thinking about it, Accord would really jump the Knights of Harmony/Order and perhaps even join them.

@Anon-a-Miss
I wonder if this was why she didn’t appear until Generations?

It didn’t really help that she was basically the main character in the rather unpopular Accord story line and the one who saved the day by talking down Accord instead of Fluttershy.

@Phoenixflambe
I agree.

@Kiryu-Chan
It’s a setup so I’m crossing my fingers, they’ll probably show up next issues. Transformers X MLP is for fun so continuity is loose and irrelevant and there are crazy stories. Zecora’s arc in Season 10 took 4 issues while the rest has been dumbed down due to studio interferences apparently so possibly it will begin next issue?

@Phoenixflambe
Cozy didn’t show up until s8 so u know..

Just got done with the first issue and it’s already off to a poor start. Guess they forgot about the G1 part of this G1/FIM crossover. At least with the Transformers crossover we got to see the actual Transformers right away. Here over half the comic is spent on shitty human OCs. I don’t care if they’re “descendants of the G1 witches”. This would have been like if instead of Transformers we got a bunch of human OCs that were related to those awful Animated human villains

@CORDZ2000
Or because less people care about what they’re doing in general.

Meanwhile Cozy’s first and only appearance in IDW is on the last page as a statue.

@RogueBadnik
People forget but starlight was once far more controversial than even Discord is now, when she was first reformed to the point that idw decided to stop showing her because of the sheer amount of backlash. Edit: guess them seeing Shes a more well received character now made them decide to bring her back.