Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Pony Arts & Prints!

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

Oh Sombra. . . What did they do to you?
 
 
welp i just spent 20 minutes adding tags, rip.

safe2185034 ahuizotl950 apple bloom60324 applejack201506 autumn blaze5451 big macintosh33732 bon bon18879 chancellor neighsay914 cheerilee11269 coco pommel7307 coloratura3555 cozy glow9627 cranky doodle donkey1219 daring do7233 derpy hooves57718 diamond tiara11869 discord37671 dj pon-333361 doctor caballeron918 filthy rich1313 fizzlepop berrytwist9915 flam2468 fleur-de-lis4594 flim2579 fluttershy259850 garble2233 gilda11402 grampa gruff483 grogar1453 king sombra17190 lightning dust5356 limestone pie6239 lord tirek6301 lyra heartstrings34206 marble pie8333 maud pie15028 mean twilight sparkle970 moondancer6120 ms. harshwhinny2720 night glider1542 nightmare moon20472 nurse redheart4398 octavia melody27701 pharynx1330 pinkie pie257117 pony of shadows640 princess cadance40245 princess celestia113167 princess ember8687 princess luna117608 queen chrysalis42346 rainbow dash281465 rarity218470 roseluck6216 scootaloo58986 shining armor28203 spike92699 spitfire15760 spoiled rich1496 star swirl the bearded2349 starlight glimmer60299 storm king1465 sugar belle3777 sunburst8881 sunset shimmer79561 sweetie belle56977 sweetie drops18879 tempest shadow19039 the sphinx1191 thorax5509 tree hugger3505 trixie79732 twilight sparkle359382 vinyl scratch33361 zecora11173 alicorn316567 centaur4704 changedling11556 changeling66281 donkey2694 draconequus20477 dragon86104 earth pony509008 goat2001 griffon36882 kirin15324 pegasus501199 pony1614127 sphinx2591 storm creature146 unicorn542882 zebra23933 g42041573 my little pony: the movie21474 alignment chart63 chart1033 flim flam brothers1460 headcanon3060 king thorax3862 personality22 prince pharynx1012 twilight sparkle (alicorn)150018 wall of tags6759
Source

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

CORDZ2000
Solar Hero - Went above and beyond for the Solar Deity, drawing from the power of the sun itself to bring balance to the fight against the Lunar Insurrection (April Fools 2023).

Draconequues Lover zcord
@MintyTwinkles
Stern, traditional, loyal to her family/business, enforcing her rules in/of her home, “if you want to stay you got to work” “ma and pa maybe own the farm but I keep it running” Limestone Pie… does not sound very rebelious to me.
That’s fair.
So, in resume Intention =/= action.
Well yeah, I consider the magnitude of damage a person does to be not entirely relevant to how evil they are or more specifically, how willing they are to harm people. A baby who finds a gun and kills someone by accident isn’t evil, and a diabolically evil genius baby isn’t NOT evil merely because it is a baby and lacks the opportunity to do harm at the moment. If someone’s intentions are innocent so are they.
Starlight isn’t “innocent” but I don’t believe she can be worthy of being called evil merely because her actions lead to great harm. She’s not TRYING to be evil, she doesn’t WANT to be evil, she’s just an irresponsible asshole on a power trip who has more access to power than she knows how to handle.
She still should have gone to jail, though.
 
U bring up some good points on how to look at it
CORDZ2000
Solar Hero - Went above and beyond for the Solar Deity, drawing from the power of the sun itself to bring balance to the fight against the Lunar Insurrection (April Fools 2023).

Draconequues Lover zcord
Don’t see the problem with that. She means well, yes, but whether her well-meaning plans work is a different story altogether.
 
 
Being failed doesn’t stop her from being a good pony maybe just not the best leader ever.
CORDZ2000
Solar Hero - Went above and beyond for the Solar Deity, drawing from the power of the sun itself to bring balance to the fight against the Lunar Insurrection (April Fools 2023).

Draconequues Lover zcord
@Warrior_Kitten
Garble tried to kill spike many times and stated his wishes to pillage and burn equestria.
@Warrior_Kitten
He led the attempt to smash the phoenix eggs. He should be a square down if anything.
In a “bad boy” attempt, it was revealed in later seasons that he’s actually a softy, just refuses to admit it. Many children have killed in their youth (ants, bugs mostly. Some have killed animals and pets) it’s not unusual. It doesn’t make them bad, just wrong.
 
That bad boy attempt was honestly a BS plot excuse as there have been no signs of it, and it doesn’t change the fact he led a group to kill babies for the kicks and is implied to have done so already in the past. Him tryna kill spike many times isnt a good excuse for i didn’t wanna look weak infront of my friends especially when he did those things not around friends. He honestly need a lot more to truly redeem himself, hes not even a interesting character or was a cool villain to make up for it.
Warrior_Kitten
Solar Supporter - Fought against the New Lunar Republic rebellion on the side of the Solar Deity (April Fools 2023).
Non-Fungible Trixie -
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!

Electric Bulwark
@Warrior_Kitten
Garble tried to kill spike many times and stated his wishes to pillage and burn equestria.
@Warrior_Kitten
He led the attempt to smash the phoenix eggs. He should be a square down if anything.
 
In a “bad boy” attempt, it was revealed in later seasons that he’s actually a softy, just refuses to admit it. Many children have killed in their youth (ants, bugs mostly. Some have killed animals and pets) it’s not unusual. It doesn’t make them bad, just wrong.
Jacalope
Non-Fungible Trixie -
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
Artist -

Noodles > Everything
@MintyTwinkles  
reformed Discord exist, but Dubuc’s Discord never exist… and Sombra is evil no matter what season.  
And Tempest done awful things meanwhile she was with Storm King.
 
 
@CORDZ2000  
How i said, Dubuc’s Discord never exist.
CORDZ2000
Solar Hero - Went above and beyond for the Solar Deity, drawing from the power of the sun itself to bring balance to the fight against the Lunar Insurrection (April Fools 2023).

Draconequues Lover zcord
@Jacalope  
Discord falls under nice towards the eos because starting with discordant harmony(matter of principles) aside, his goals and his actions he did ultimately to help his friends at times often in his own chaotic ways whether he was successful or not.
MintyTwinkles

And of course, i put the female draconequus in the list.
 
Y’know I thought you meant non-birb Eris and I was about to applaud you on your tastes but Discord is already on the chart and i am dumb.
 
I’m okay with these changes, and actually I kinda like the idea of Tempest being Civic, as she largely was just following orders. Do you really think she’s evil though?
 
Also a little funny apparently in your eyes reformed Discord and Season 9 Sombra literally do not exist.
Jacalope
Non-Fungible Trixie -
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
Artist -

Noodles > Everything
full
 
I think this is more accurate at least for my knowledge. And of course, i put the female draconequus in the list.
MintyTwinkles

@MintyTwinkles
Stern, traditional, loyal to her family/business, enforcing her rules in/of her home, “if you want to stay you got to work” “ma and pa maybe own the farm but I keep it running” Limestone Pie… does not sound very rebelious to me.
 
That’s fair.
 
 
@Jacalope  
So, in resume Intention =/= action.
 
Well yeah, I consider the magnitude of damage a person does to be not entirely relevant to how evil they are or more specifically, how willing they are to harm people. A baby who finds a gun and kills someone by accident isn’t evil, and a diabolically evil genius baby isn’t NOT evil merely because it is a baby and lacks the opportunity to do harm at the moment. If someone’s intentions are innocent so are they.
 
Starlight isn’t “innocent” but I don’t believe she can be worthy of being called evil merely because her actions lead to great harm. She’s not TRYING to be evil, she doesn’t WANT to be evil, she’s just an irresponsible asshole on a power trip who has more access to power than she knows how to handle.
 
She still should have gone to jail, though.
Jacalope
Non-Fungible Trixie -
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
Artist -

Noodles > Everything
@MintyTwinkles
 
I wouldn’t say more dangerous. Ahui seems a bit more malicious and willing to act evil or do harm than OG Starlight, who was on a crazy egoistic power trip. And Garble’s a straight bully. [/bq]
 
But who made more damage? a single guardian or someone who broke the timeline 7 times just for revenge?
 
It’s like comparing Screwball with Magneto, okay, Screwball is a bad person but she just made tricks for fame and likes, nothing serious like Magneto who despiste he wants to keep the mutans save, makes a genocide.
 
It’s impossible not making Glimmer less evil than Ahui.
 
So, in resume Intention =/= action.
Backgroundpony
Non-Fungible Trixie -

@MintyTwinkles  
Stern, traditional, loyal to her family/business, enforcing her rules in/of her home, “if you want to stay you got to work” “ma and pa maybe own the farm but I keep it running” Limestone Pie… does not sound very rebelious to me.
MintyTwinkles

I dont even get why are here so much Comments
 
Not sure either , but I suppose I should probably respond to some of them.
 
 
@Jacalope  
why Ahuizotl is more dangerous than unreformed Starlight Glimmer?
Ahuizotl isn’t evil, it was proven that he was simply misunderstood and was trying to protect the artifacts from Daring and others, so he shouldn’t be where he is.
Garble similarly wouldn’t kick a puppy, should be neutral.
 
 
I wouldn’t say more dangerous. Ahui seems a bit more malicious and willing to act evil or do harm than OG Starlight, who was on a crazy egoistic power trip. And Garble’s a straight bully.
 
 
@Background Pony #D58B  
Lightning Dust is 100% at least naughty. She almost killed five of the mane six and blew it off like it was just another Monday then went and almost killed Scootaloo just to get revenge on Rainbow Dash. She’s a sociopath.
 
I view Lightning Dust as a cocky idiot who doesn’t mean to harm anyone but also doesn’t care if she does. So what MetaKnight said.
 
 
@Background Pony #1FF5  
Celestia would fit “Lawful” better.
 
I actually agree with you. I think Celestia is just Lawful even though she actually IS the supreme authority in the land, because being wise and benevolent as she is she would understand that behaving too authoritarian would not be a beneficial thing for other people. I put her in Authoritarian anyway just because I figured people would complain a bunch if I didn’t, due to her status as an authority. But Celly’s the only character on this chart whose alignment I kinda forced a little bit.
 
 
@CORDZ2000  
Its worth to note that the characters in nice are capable of being the ones in Good or even altruist, but I can see this being a representation of how they are generally.
 
Yeah that’s correct. Character behavior is fluid as well as open to interpretation, so everything on the chart is “on average/generally”. Everyone has off days and a chart like this can’t reflect everything a person is capable of. I did feel a bit awkward determining these character’s moral worth, it feels insulting to those placed in Nice that they are “not good enough” but realistically people are just varying levels of good. But don’t undersell nice. Nice is nice! It’s a good thing to be nice! Those characters are just less idealistic.
 
 
@Kamazeustra  
The Storm King isn’t anarchist in the slightest. He’s absolutely authoritarian.
 
You might be right there. I guess I put him there because he causes a lot of ruckus and acts wildly, without lingering on him too much. To be fair I only saw the movie once. Although I would say just because a villain wants everyone to obey THEM doesn’t mean they have any care for authority otherwise.
 
 
@Wayneponeth  
Santa’s list is a lot more complicated than I thought
 
I AM Santa.
 
@OtherFritz  
S2 Discord under naughty? Isn’t the description of Eldritch essentially his MO?
 
Yeah so I definitely didn’t use the best term there. Eldritch doesn’t mean evil, it means frightening and monstrous in an otherworldly way. I needed SOME word to be worse than Evil and I just felt like that sounded nice. I was gonna go with Unholy but I wanted a more exotic term that conveys being evil beyond just everyday cruelty.
 
 
@CORDZ2000  
@OtherFritz
hes labeled as what a Eldritch Abomination is but thats like a species, based of on how he is s2 Discord does fall up under naughty(kicking a puppy and turning ponyvillie into the chaos capital of the world) as he’s alternate universe future was less worse than the other villains and his mind control while cruel wasn’t as much intended evil as other villains later on done the line. Puppy is a label for innocent being here.
@Background Pony #D58B
yes lightning dust is a type book sociopath but she doesn’t really go out of her way to kick a puppy specifically even if she never has any remorse with who can get hurt from her actions, but i mean our we gonna put her in the same scale of yes all characters i love tempest, discord and starlight but characters who love for them withstanding still tried to take over kingdoms, brainwash others and such for self-serving reasons lol.
 
Right again. It’s fine though you can easily argue Lightning Dust is Naughty. She hasn’t acted innocent, it depends on how you view her.
 
@Backgroundpony  
Tge Storm King and Limestone feel very bad placed
@Backgroundpony
I feel like the storm king is Lawful Evil he had a whole system.
 
Storm King yeah alright maybe. What’s wrong with Limey? She does seem like kind of a rebel but, not malicious or nice in any real way.