Uploaded by đ´ 
1545x720 JPG 1.15 MB
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
Description
No description provided.
Tags
+-SH editor needed261 +-SH source needed26610 +-SH safe2230862 +-SH edit178303 +-SH edited screencap94092 +-SH screencap300401 +-SH applejack205125 +-SH fluttershy265059 +-SH pinkie pie261958 +-SH rainbow dash286615 +-SH rarity222551 +-SH spike93937 +-SH starlight glimmer61633 +-SH sunny starscout23176 +-SH twilight sparkle366110 +-SH alicorn327347 +-SH dragon89477 +-SH earth pony529096 +-SH pegasus521437 +-SH pony1660937 +-SH unicorn564857 +-SH g42093335 +-SH g581666 +-SH my little pony: a new generation14987 +-SH alternate timeline3873 +-SH diagram257 +-SH female1868194 +-SH gradient background28904 +-SH headcanon3220 +-SH mane seven8076 +-SH mane six38337 +-SH mare781946 +-SH multiverse theory3 +-SH older42039 +-SH older applejack1110 +-SH older fluttershy1098 +-SH older mane seven318 +-SH older mane six492 +-SH older pinkie pie1049 +-SH older rainbow dash1387 +-SH older rarity1040 +-SH older spike9495 +-SH older twilight4578 +-SH theory499 +-SH twilight sparkle (alicorn)152870
Loading...
Loading...
Multiverse Theoryâs a bitch.
Edited
Edited
Iâd wager Chrysalis intended to kill them. She literally violently splattered a bunny in front of the CMC for shits and giggles.
True. But even then, after stating that they should show that theyâve broken their heroes first, she follows that up with âBesides, we should have fun with our guestsâ - AKA, what she considers âfunâ is more important to her than killing. Unpleasant almost certainly, but not murderous.
Edited
It should be noted that on the topic of âChrysalis,â she made sure to emphasize in the same vein of âso⌠permanentâ that they should show the rest of Equestria that theyâd âbroken their heroes first,â and that she vocally objected on the basis of âpatience, Cozyâ and for whatever it was worth, fake Rainbow Dash in the alternate timeline chose the wording of âwe barely escaped with our lives,â which could be validly interpreted as âthey were known to kill ponies, even if itâs great to have them as slaves,â if it was meant to sound believable.
Edited
âThis theoryâ as in the theory depicted in the image? As much as I love to dunk on many-worlds hypotheses, I have to agree. If the separation of timelines depends on quantum rules, residual magic (such as cutie marks) still bleeds over into the world of G5 but not in a form accessible to ponies.
Regardless, I think this theory wouldâve fit very well with the new series more than just the standard âeverything went to shitâ scenario.
Thereâs a vast difference between âI am become time, destroyer of empiresâ and screwing it up within living memory of happily ever after.
this image was made before TYT
But Twilight not dying in the original timeline means her ghost wouldnât exist in that timeline, nor did Twilight leave behind the amount of material that even Discord needed to recreate Sombra.
Nothing lasts forever
If you want to be that petulantly pedantic about definitions, fine. Itâs not technically a retcon, as none of the on-screen events are contradicted. Only the entire emotional resolution was undone with ââŚjk, no they didnâtâ after a clear happily ever after. Itâs like when they place the sequel hook in the middle of the credits of a capeshit superhero movie.
Point is each timeline wouldâve made harder if not impossible for the next villain to have gained power in those circumstances. You CAN make the arguments like maybe Cadence still met Shining or Maybe Tirek found a way to absorb power, but given thereâs no absolute indication as to how things played out, Occamâs Razor would state Celestia found a way regardless.
âAnd Discord enslaves them alive, showing all other threats must have been defeatedâ
NMM is known to only imprison Celestia in the moon, Chrysalis is known for wanting to have âfunâ with her âguestsâ and considering âdestructionâ awfully permanent etc. TBH, Sombra and Tirek are most likely to be lethal, but Sombra has his mind-control capabilities which would make killing powerful opponents wasteful.
Edited
That would make it worse as it would mean those timelines and their inhabitance were destroyed as opposed to continuing where they had hope for a better ending (only 2 were bad enough to be a clear mercy kill.
Itâs not a retcon if the change was after the point the show ended. The change has enough problems we donât want to discredit ourselves with inaccurate complaints.
man if only somebody had spent an embarrassing amount of time meticulously speculating on what a nightmare moon ruled equestria would be like and how she interacted with all the other villains, thatâd be so cool
They showed a happily ever after and then picked one of the stupidest ways to retcon it.
But G4 does end in a happily ever after. And the orignal universe and the new universe were technically the same universe. That Sonic Rainboom seen at the end of Cutie Re-Mark - Part 2 have restored the entire timeline and possibly eradicated the bad ones.
Just let people have their own headcanons.
Just accept that G4 doesnât end in a happily ever after.