Jesus, that’s depressing. Poor Ponk.

Well I’m afraid it’s too late for human pinkie pie because human shining armor is smitten over human cadence just the real couple who have flurry heart. As for sunset it’s best to just live in the moment in the human world and hang out with human twilight and the rest of her human friends. And puppy spike.

@Background Pony #F2D1
but it is not real, because if it were it would be shown in the series but it wasn’t. Rarity, Applejack, and just about any of the girls were shown romantically by a guy on the specials and tv show, not like it was in the book.

Yeah right, like that’s totally real.

@Background Pony #23A3
Agreed. Not canon.

@Background Pony #FEF6  
@Background Human  
@Background Pony #F992  
this is not canon. this book is not connected to the current canon. Then why does applejack crush on Dirk Thistleweed, a guy who looks like the male version of rarity? This was completely real. Jonathan does not exist in the current canon of equestria girls, This relationship is unrequited romances, it’s deep love experienced by the person who longs to be loved and is rejected by someone. Sandalwood is the only character that was real but has never shown romance with Fluttershy what it says in the book. all of that have never been shown in the series.

I love these two.

Pinkie Pie, you yaying homewrecker.
 
@Background Pony #5BD6  
I get the feeling it’s someone who was made expressly for the purpose of answering this question and DHX has no idea he exists. You know, like how nobody told them about Ray.

@Background Pony #5BD6  
As far as I know, nope

Did we ever learn who Jonathan is?

@Background Pony #5BD6  
Appears so

So we can comment now?

@Background Human  
Awww, but why? It seems fine for now

@Darth Shy  
No, they’re locked. You shouldn’t have been able to post. Go to the bug thread and let ’em know.

So, are these comments still open?

@Background Pony #2584  
err…no.

Welp I think I found a waifu stealer…

@Background Pony #2584  
Rarity is a apple cultivar?
 
LOL

@Background Pony #2584  
This all sounds rather unlikely.

RD let’s just say Soarin  
SS will might with flash or Sci-twi

Rarity is Applejack’s childhood friend and best friend

Jonathon=Rarity

@Background Pony #2584  
Nah.