Uploaded by Masem 
549x767 JPG 85 kB
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
Description
Given that Enterplay has had access to S4 materials for some time, this is more fuel for the “Tirek was the Pony of Shadows” fire.
Oh it’s been so long.
In Earth’s mythology (and presumably Equestria’s as well) Cerberus is the only being that guards the gate to Tartarus. Besides, how would anyone even know how many “people” should be there in the first place? It’s not like Equestrian society is the best at keeping up with their baddies.
Are they saying no one noticed the empty cage up until now?
Pretty sure they’re just making a card for a children’s card game….
I’ve actually said once before that if they want to keep FiM fresh for the long run, they might want to look into adapting some of the IDW comic stories in the future.
How do we “cite” a negative?
True, but considering Tirek made his debut in the back alley of some undisclosed Equestrian city, he has been on the move. I’m not arguing that this is solid evidence of him the Pony of Shadows, because it is a sketchy theory.
She was there multiple times.
Maybe he didn’t get a good look, at the time.
Closest that I’ve seen is when asked on Twitter, Jayson’s reply was a simple “Hehe”.
I like the theory - they make it clear that he was gaining strength and only powerful to be a threat when he could actually start draining magic, but the plot hole of not having seen Twilight (Even just seeing her as an alicorn) sorta breaks the key plot point of the finale.
It’s possible, but the likelihood isn’t exactly concrete.
Nothing but tantalizing so far.
This will only change if someone official flat out states it otherwise. (Have they?)
I figured that was at least the intent, since he was all cloaked and everything.
Like Evil the Cat or that small duckling from Courage.
[citation needed]
This is just back pedaling to try and make that inexplicable slough of pointless, last second twists seem like they were anything but lazy writing.