Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Sky Railroad Merch Shop!

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

No description provided.

safe2259960 edit180017 edited screencap95049 editor:korora1191 screencap302084 applejack207417 rarity225197 strawberry sunrise471 g42120350 honest apple836 my little pony: friendship is magic266972 angry38335 applejack's hat16102 backhanded apology1 cowboy hat28020 cropped62694 dialogue99625 hat132547 ponyville8666 speech bubble43717 strawberry savage61 that pony sure does hate apples15
Source

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

HyaenusDominae

vacant expression
I’ve realized now that I don’t necessarily hate Strawberry Sunrise or what she said to Applejack. I hate the episode Honest Apple and in particular this scene for equating her and Applejack’s attitudes.
HyaenusDominae

vacant expression
  1. Strawberry gave a pretty poor reason for not liking apples. Literally, “They’re not strawberries.” That has nothing to do with why someone shouldn’t like apples. It makes her sound like she literally only eats strawberries, and i generally wouldn’t trust that sort of person’s opinion of any food.  
  2. Applejack said apples were better than strawberries. She didn’t say strawberries were bad.  
  3. Strawberry said apples were bad. She crossed a line.  
  4. Strawberries may be Strawberry’s favorite food, but apples are Applejack’s living. What she did was arguably worse than what Alllejack did.
     
    Also, Honest Apple is a pretty poor episode overall, and this scene really sealed it for a lot of people. Rarity asked Applejack to do a job she had no interest in wouldn’t be good at. Rarity, showing no foresight, told Applejack to essentially trust her instincts. Applejack then did just that and treated fashion the way treated most things, and Rarity got mad at Applejack for doing exactly what Rarity should have known she would do. Granted, Applejack was needlessly mean when she destroyed those “fashion” “designers’” “work,” but that’s all she did wrong, or at least the only thing she did wrong that wasn’t a direct result of Rarity asking her to be there. Then we’re treated to scene where Applejack’s cornered, insulted, browbeaten, and kind of shamed into apologizing for stuff that mosyly wasn’t her fault, and this strawberry tart essentially served Rarity’s rhetorical beating stick.
     
    That’s why people don’t like her.
     
    There’s also just the fact that (for me anyway) when your a fan of Applejack, then an episode about fashion will probably put a bad taste in your mouth, since Applejack doesn’t like fashion, and her fans probably don’t either, and any scene where Applejack is forced to suffer will just make that feeling worse.
     
    I’m not saying you’re necessarily wrong. I’m just explaining how we (or at least I) feel.
Neko Majin C
Pixel Perfection - Hot Pockets Spotted
Lunar Supporter - Helped forge New Lunar Republic's freedom in the face of the Solar Empire's oppressive tyrannical regime (April Fools 2023).
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Preenhub - We all know what you were up to this evening~
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!

Twilight's Westley
People get this scene wrong. Strawberry is not in the wrong here. Rarity was the one who went up to her house, knocked on her door, and asked her to tell Applejack how she felt about apples. All Strawberry said, in the most sweet and cheerful tone possible, was that she did not like them. Then, when Applejack, in shock, asked why, she said that it was because they were not strawberries. A perfectly acceptable answer. He name is Strawberry, after all. Strawberries are her favorite food. She likes them so much, her house has a strawberry themed wallpaper. Applejack was then the one who got defensive and irate on this mare’s doorstep, this mare’s own home. Insulting her favorite food by saying apples, which Strawberry does not are for, are better than strawberries. After that, all Strawberry did was defend herself, and ultimately, won their little debate.
Background Pony #65A4
@nightshroud96  
I remember finding the episode weird because it seemed to portray ANY criticism as wrong or hurtful. Like, none of Applejack’s criticisms on the first day were even all that harsh (before she starts going nuts with it), she just pointed out she didn’t get certain design choices and she asked about the logic behind certain designs, which the designers had no response for. This is also the entire reason Rarity brought Applejack on board, to provide a “practical” insight to everything.
 
And yet it’s portrayed like it was wrong for her to speak out at all and you never get that moment of why Applejack being practical was supposed to be useful critique, so Rarity just comes off looking like a moron for bringing her in in the first place. I don’t even think they show a “proper” way to give critique for comparison, it’s just “be careful of hurting feelings.”
SinnerWhoKeepsTrying1978
Solar Supporter - Fought against the New Lunar Republic rebellion on the side of the Solar Deity (April Fools 2023).

I am human, hear me err.
“Yeah, Sunrise, and as everybody knows, nothing could possibly happen to the miraculous strawberry.”
 
[insert images of a strawberry covered in mold, a strawberry eaten by caterpillars, a strawberry dehydrated, a strawberry multicolored due to shade, a strawberry otherwise deformed]
nightshroud96
Lunar Supporter - Helped forge New Lunar Republic's freedom in the face of the Solar Empire's oppressive tyrannical regime (April Fools 2023).

Strawberry Sunrise pisses me off a bunch.  
Before someone goes “Its to teach Applejack honesty can hurt” or something.  
Applejack was clearly not purposely trying to piss Rarity off iirc, she was just saying what she thinks.  
Not exactly sure since I didn’t see the clip but I do know its not like how Strawberry was doing it.  
Strawberry was purposely saying it to get on Applejacks nerves, like show knows it will piss her off. Like twisting the knife in. And that annoying smug look just shows she knows she can and will get away with it because “morals”.
 
The lesson here is honesty is good, but don’t try to sound like an asshole. If Applejack came off as that, I am sure she didn’t intentionally do it. Strawberry however, was clearly doing so(and I am sure it was worse than what happened in Applejack’s case). That’s the huge problem here.
 
Yeah.. just ranting since that scene there in the episode sure got on my nerves.
Softy
Non-Fungible Trixie -
Wallet After Summer Sale -
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!

There’s no such thing as a “mealyworm”. There is a “mealworm”, but that’s not what she’s saying.
 
Strawberry says “tasteless, mealy, worm-filled things”. She’s saying the apples are mealy and also filled with worms. They’re not filled with mealyworms, because there’s no such thing.
HyaenusDominae

vacant expression
I actually hate this pony. Normally I think less of people for having emotional attachments to characters, but I actually hate her. She’s the only fictiknal character who elicits an emotional reaction from me, and it’s one of pure hatred and rage.