@otherone
Oh, no. No, I can’t think of a case where that’s ever happened before. Wouldn’t really be fair to the people who earned the badge the first time, would it?
Let me go further, if it helps.
It entirely depends on the badge, doesn’t it? Some badges can be used again and again. Others are only given to ONE person EVER. Still more badges are from events that are never going to be repeated. Others are from events that could repeat every 10 years.
The badge you asked about is “Princess of Love - Extra special version for those who participated in the Canterlot Wedding 10th anniversary event by contributing art.” So, maybe at the next 10 years anniversary it could happen again. Or, maybe someone will create an even more amazing badge.
So, maybe it will get reused. But whenever we’ve done something where a past badge might have been reused, we make a new one because artists love to create beautiful badges.