Re-reading all the comments here made me temporarily get air caught in my esophagus. XD

why couldnt this happen to me?

@Background Pony #1BC9  
Get a life satch. :)

@Background Pony #CE40  
Well thank you A.J.P. Taylor. Lol
 
 
@ManualReplica  
that’s rich ya know, coming from the same artist who cannot tell the difference between…yeah, you know what I’m talkin’ about. :p
 
If the image is meant to provoke arousal in the viewer, then what is the issue?

@Background Pony #CC51
 

@Sky_Wolf  
“why can’t we have rape as a standalone so people could subscribe to grimdark and not get lots of meaningless sex stuff which has NOTHING dark in it?”  
Maybe one day you’ll be staff to make that happen. I also hate random sex pics in a worthless category too. One day they’ll finally unclog their ears and listen.

@Background Pony #0F68  
Mm. The most logical response that is of course not always enacted is to add the applicable tag(s) to an image such that it is then filtered by one’s hide list. However, as demonstrated countless times, some users do not add said tag(s) and instead whine profusely towards those who honestly don’t give a shit about some anonymous online individual’s personal preferences. X3

reads all the drama funny enough, I believe that Sky- whatevers problem was technically already solved, they just needed to filter semi grimdark, which is what this pic is tagged as, and while it’s not a total solution, I think it would drastically reduce this whole ‘finding non-grimdark rape’ thing he was extensively arguing about. Feel free to correct me if I’m wrong, i just come here to look at pony porn, not participate in lengthy discussions on ‘proper tagging’ :T

@The Smiling Pony  
Hey, if I were a single dad I’d totally let her finish, but then preach to her that was a one-time only thing, that fathers and daughters shouldn’t do those things.

Dashie, Worship my cock as you do his <3

Someone really loves her daddy

@lolstarderp  
No need to over-dramatize =P

@Maya  
And you KNOW it’s gone to hell when Maya has to say the Fun was Certainly not doubled this day.

@ThePornMaestro  
Ladies and gentlemen, This is how you know you Dun Fucked up.
 
If you ever start to agree with/share this… I-don’t-have-a-word-for-it-in-my-exponential-vocabulary type person’s Ideals and Beliefs, Please, immediately put down your illegal substances, Get up off your arse, Find the nearest person, Ask about the nearest Sanitarium, go there, and tell the person at the desk “I’d like to check in, indefinitely.”
 
REALLY, people, we should write this moment down, for this is a perfect example of How Not to Society.
 
That is all.

It’ll get thicker, Dashie!

@Maya
 
Yep. =t

@Mr. Ghostman  

>Raincest
 
>Drama in the comments
 
>rape, semi-grimdark tag
 
>Fav’d for Raincest
 
I don’t even……..

@ManualReplica  
@paluzna  
@The Smiling Pony  
Y’all have some good points; I wanted to explain why I figured this might not be as traumatic as violent rape, but the real point originally is that regardless of the potential consequences/severity of the incident that this still qualifies as a rape.

@Background Pony #E172
 
True, but it’s not a competition over how dark and mentally traumatizing it is.
 
Of course if make a comparison similar to “getting your hand chopped off isn’t as bad as becoming a vegetable all your life” you’ll agree that one is “less bad” than the other, but the fact remains in the end that they are both bad things.
 
Ergo in our context we can say that yes, this is less grimdark than a pic of a mare being gangbanged and abused in a public restroom or in an alley, with visible abuse, crying and every red flag in the book, but it still remains grimdark nonetheless due to the implications and scenario.
 
The bottomline will always remain “rape is rape, no matter how you put it”.
 
Do you see what I’m getting at?

@Background Pony #90C4  
nvm, i read “rape porn” as “rape”  
it isnt rape porn as long as the focus inst on the act itself, obviously.
 
this site being a booru, makes it irrelevant whether the focus is on it or not, if its on the pic, it has to be taged.
 
 
“Also, please, please, please, no ad hominem or flame based replies. A simple yes/no with an explanation will do. And if things get out of hand, then this line of questioning can end.”  
as long as people dont act like assholes they should not worry about being atacked.
 
 
@Background Pony #E172  
>implying normal people would be rational about it.

@Background Pony #E172  
It’s not about her possibly being wrong in the head, but about never being able to forget that moment, all the feelings, her face, everything, every time you looked at her. And her being old enough to remember it all for the rest of her life, as well, every time she looks at you, or has any sexual thoughts. You can rationalize it as “it was just a confused kid thing”, but the brain doesn’t really work like that.

@The Smiling Pony  
@ManualReplica  
I suppose I was thinking that the reaction, after the shock was over, would be “okay, my daughter is confused, she’s at a weird age and maybe has a problem or is a little fucked up”. I think the assumption would be that her naivete lead to an inappropriate situation, something pretty common for children (though generally to a lesser degree obviously), rather than “oh god, my daughter is a twisted perv and a rapist!”
 
Compare that to the trauma of being violently raped by some disgusting stranger, and I’d say it’s not as bad. It’s subjective tho, so I guess others could find it worse.

@Background Pony #E172
 
I’m not sure about you, but I was a parent I’d be pretty horrified if my kids tried to fuck me or their mother in our sleep.
 
Morally, to a lot you, this doesn’t seem like a huge deal since its fem RD x her dad, under the subconscious reasoning that “female on male rape doesn’t appear to be as bad as the reverse”.
 
But in a reverse scenario where it’d have been say, a son penetrating his mother in her sleep, or a dad doing the same to her daughter, in a scenario where it’s heavily implied that the receiving party doesn’t share the feeling/hasn’t consented to sex previously you’d look at it a lot differently.
 
It doesn’t seem to outlandish to think that a female on male rape pic, of say, a female OC forcibly riding or blowing the male in an alley, hospital bed, or whatever, would get the same kind of reaction of “how is this grimdark?” if it isn’t super implied by visual cues.

@Background Pony #E172  
I suspect waking up to your 6-9yo daughter giving you a blowjob would fuck most “normal” people up more than your example, personally.