@Yet One More Idiot
Maybe Rarity likes the rags to riches story of Oliver. I like to headcanon Rarity had a somewhat gritty childhood that she doesn’t talk a lot about.

Spike: South Park Bigger Longer and Uncut Grins mischievously  
Twilight: Don’t you dare  
Spike: Shut your fucking face, Uncle Fucka  
You’re a cock sucking, ass licking Uncle Fucka  
You’re an Uncle Fucka, yes, it’s true  
Nobody fucks uncles quite like you
 
Shut your fucking face, Uncle Fucka  
You’re the one that fucked your uncle, Uncle Fucka  
You don’t eat or sleep or mow the lawn  
You just fuck your uncle all day long
 
Fucker, fucker, Uncle Fucka  
Uncle Fucka, Uncle Fucka
 
Shut your fucking face, Uncle Fucka  
You’re a boner biting bastard, Uncle Fucka  
You’re an Uncle Fucka, I must say  
We fucked your uncle yesterday
 
Uncle Fucka that’s U N C L E  
Fuck you, Uncle Fucka, get out  
Suck my balls

@Mugen Kagemaru  
…I hope you grab Opal by mistake.

@Scrounge
 
… No.

@Mugen Kagemaru  
Can I have one of his feet?

And Angel is now a dead rabbit walking.

To be honest, I would’ve thought Rarity’s and Dashie’s answers would’ve been the other way around. Dashie hardly seems the type to enjoy the Sound Of Music, and Rarity seems too refined for Oliver! to be her fave. :)

Would have thought AJ would like Oklahoma. Or maybe that’d be more Braeburn’s thing. I dunno.

@Yet_One_More_Idiot  
>>599339

@Background Pony #142D  
This meme will come full-circle when somepony makes a copy of this meme where Twiley asks her friends which use of this meme they enjoyed most.
 
And now I’ve suggested that, it’s pretty dang sure to happen soon. :P

@Ferrotter  
I’d probably would have her like either Avenue Q or a really bad musical (i.e. Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark).

This is the most overused meme in Derpibooru.

Maud: “The Book of Mormon. I appreciate biting satire.”

@IpersonallylikeCupcakes  
Mmm, best pies in London.

I would’ve figured Fluttershy would like “The Lion King.” However, that’s not a punchline.

Sweeney Todd
 
It’s so good.

I would jess with Applejack to say that she would love OKLAHOMA!

I mainly used musicals that seem to me to have the Elements of Harmony as an central, upheld virtue, other than Twilight (who I hadn’t realized needed an opinion before I sat down to make this and was looking at templates) and Fluttershy (who’s punchline opinion is my way of venting frustration at Carousel after seeing it for the first time last night).

=@YukoAsho  
I would’ve sai Rarity and Rainbow Dash seem to have swapped answers somehow. xD

Dash would go for West Side Story or something silly like that.

I’d have pegged Rarity for Phantom of the Opera.