@Yurp  
And all I’m saying is that if you put Trixie in these villain lists, then you also need to put Luna; not Nightmare Moon, but Luna. Or you give her the Alicorn Amulet and glowing red eyes.
 
And yes, Flim & Flam are pretty high up in the bad guys list. And the Diamond Dogs even higher.

@Background Pony
 
I’m entirely okay with nightmare moon being on that list. Evil is evil is evil.
 
Maybe specify that it is Trixie under the influence of the amulet or some such thing. I mean hell if we are going to count gilda then I’d go as far as to say Flim and Flam are worse because they were going to completely throw a family on the streets without a second thought to make a quick bit while Gilda was, as i said, nothing but a playground bully who when RD s think Flim or Flam would have done thaid “chill out or gtfo” she just left without a word. And I know that Flim and Flam would never do the same (albiet that has more to do with niether of them having a personal relationship with anyone in ponyville at the time). Though I wont argue the point for flim and flam because it’s getting a bit off topic.
 
All I’m saying is that I think there are those better suited for Gilda’s spot.

@Yurp  
You’re forgetting that Trixie was very explicitly under the influence of an artifact that made her both crazy and evil, meaning her actions weren’t indicative of her character. If Trixie is to be classed as evil, than so is sweet Princess Luna.
 
As for Sunset Shimmer, still can’t comment, but I imagine there was a something that made her repent.

@Yurp  
Tea Time with Sombra would be better.  
“Isn’t this Tea delightful Mister Sombra?”  
“DIS TEA IS SHIT! I WUNA CRYSTALS”

@Background Pony
 
repent or not you are comparing some playground bully to someone who will enslave an entire town over a petty vendetta against one individual and one who would steal an ancient power to raise an army of mindslaves to take over the world.
 
The worse gilda would do is take your lunch money and shove you around- maybe.
 
that being said Tea Time with Chrysalis sounds delightful :)

@Yurp  
But Trixie did repent at the end of Magic Duel, and as far as I know so did Sunset Shimmer at the end of EG (haven’t seen yet).
 
Gilda is still a liar, thief, bully and violent brute. I’d rather have tea time with Chrysalis than a thuggish brute like Gilda.

Trixie fits well enough thanks to magic duel but I’m not so sure gilda belongs in this group. Sunset Shimmer maybe but Gilda was just a jerk, she didn’t really try to overthrow equestria or take a horrible vengeance or some other third thing

Replace Killtuh with Sunset Boulevard Shimmer and you may be on to something.
 
 
@ZeroSpawn47  
Right about Trixie, was nice to see Snips and Snails being portrayed as more malevolent, considering their fuck-ups caused Ponyville and Trixie such grief!

@RIG  
Dunno, Iron Wheel reminded me a lot of companies that catch nasty lawsuits for minor flaws in their products, stemming largely from their customers being retards.

except trixie was never evil and gilda was just a jerk

Nightmare Moon–Element of Treachery  
Trixie–Element of Greed  
Gilda–Element of Cruelty  
King Sombra–Element of Fear  
Queen Chrysalis–Element of Deception  
Discord–Element of Chaos

@Twinhead-B  
is 50% of the fault for eahc one, Iron will for not addindg a “limit”, Fluttershy for “taking it too far”.

the best characters

@The Smiling Pony
 
True enough, but he did create the problem.
 
Semantics I say!

@Twinhead-B  
if Iron Will had acted like a jerk after fluttershy claimed no be satisfied he would have been a jerk in everyone eyes, but he didn’t, he accepted defeat and even learned something: “No means no, no pony has ever told me that before…HEY! that is a good one! i may use it in my next speeches!”

@Twinhead-B  
Iron Will wasn’t the episode antagonist, Fluttershy was. Iron Will was as much an antagonist in ‘Putting your hoof down’ as Spike was in ‘Boast Busters’.

@MonkeyDzyrax
 
Eh, Blueblood’s kinda lame. How about Rover (or any of the other Diamond Dogs)?

@Twinhead-B  
Blueblood has more Chnaces of returning as An Antagonist than Iron Will, If Iron Will Returns he wont be an Antagonist because he doesnt have a reason to. Blueblood on the other hand Is Like Prince Charming from Shrek two(Prince Charming wasnt really evil until shrek three)

@MonkeyDzyrax
 
How so? He just acted like a snob for all of about five minutes of the whole episode.
 
At least Iron Will was the main antagonist in his episode…

@MonkeyDzyrax  
*Will

@Twinhead-B  
But he was More of an antagonist than Iron Wi..

@MonkeyDzyrax
 
Eh, not really much of a nemesis, he was really just a jerk..

@Twinhead-B  
Blueblood?

@SpacePaladin
 
Why not have Lightning Dust as Rainbow’s, Iron Will as Fluttershy’s and Gilda as Pinkie Pie’s?.
 
Flim and Flam could work for Applejack. Now we just need one for Rarity…

@Twinhead-B
 
I have a headcanon where Gilda took Iron Will’s courses when she was younger. That way, we could make Lightning Dust Rainbow Dash’s counterpart, and Gilda Fluttershy’s.
 
Applejack’s counterpart would probably be Flim and Flam. They’re dishonest people who take advantage of their marks, but at the same time, they actually do research on their prospective clientèle instead of relying solely on the fact that they are the providers to get people to buy their stuff.