Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Ministry of Image - Fanfiction Printing

Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!

Description

A counterpoint.

Comments

Syntax quick reference: **bold** *italic* ||hide text|| `code` __underline__ ~~strike~~ ^sup^ %sub%

Detailed syntax guide

That one guy....

Ahh yes, BUT….Those vermin threatened her very livelihood. Her means to survive. Farming pays her bills and puts food on her table. So, like any good farmer, she wanted to stamp out any threat to her farm.  
And if that means brainwashing a bunch of bats to make ’em fuckoff, so be it.
WM-R
Speaking Fancy - For helping with translations

@Mayojar77
 
That’s…admittedly a new one. I’ll add it to my list of descriptions for durian.
 
And the funny thing is that isn’t that inaccurate a description. Monthong durian are nice and soft, with a custard-like texture. The flooded sewer part would be the raw power of the scent.
WM-R
Speaking Fancy - For helping with translations

@PonyPon
 
Ah. The smell is incredibly pungent. I’ve heard it compared to rotting meat in terms of how strong the smell is.
 
I’ve even seen people so repelled they actually had to leave the room. The smell is just too much.
 
Tastes delicious, though.
Techy Pony

@Millennial Dan  
“As you’ve said, Twilight gets more of the spotlight than the others, and she has also been promoted to pretty pony princess, so yes, it wouldn’t be extreme or unfair to say that a little more is expected from her.”
 
I know this feel more or less being the “perfect child” of our family. More is expected of you and when you can’t meet these impossibly high standards people get pissed at you, even though those standards are higher than anything you’ve shown being capable of.
 
Sure, higher standards are acceptable, but it’s not like becoming a princess did anything to change her and make her flawless (a mary sue), so give her some slack in the mean time.
Millennial Dan
Artist -

@Techy Pony  
There’s no doubt that reason was pretty much breaking down by that point, so Twilight’s mistake was understandable enough. However, that doesn’t mean she couldn’t have learned from it.
 
They all have personal stuff to work on. As you’ve said, Twilight gets more of the spotlight than the others, and she has also been promoted to pretty pony princess, so yes, it wouldn’t be extreme or unfair to say that a little more is expected from her.
Techy Pony

@Millennial Dan  
Not necessarily, maybe they figured eating their buildings and having to rebuild was better than eating all their food and starving. Plus as you could tell by the end of that episode it was crazy stressful and Twilight looked like she was going mad. Maybe the reverse spell didn’t just come to mind. (Also, there being a reverse spell doesn’t necessarily mean she knows it, but could be implemented if need be) It was a shot in the dark, but no one else had any ideas to stop them, and had they not done something then they’d surely be screwed. Sure pinkie had a plan, but no one knew that because pinkie is freaking stupid sometimes. Had pinkie been intelligible then there’d be less destruction (to food and buildings).
 
tl;dr Yes is was a risk, but they didn’t exactly have many options did they?
Millennial Dan
Artist -

@Techy Pony  
If what she did to the parasprites was reversible, wouldn’t she have done so? That was one of those times when she didn’t have a clear idea of what would result from her wild shot in the dark, and didn’t seem to have any idea of how to undo it.
Techy Pony

@Millennial Dan  
“It was… semi-dire, a chaotic situation that needed quick looking after. More or less.”
 
The parasprites were very dire and very chaotic and needed a quick solution….
 
“And at least the effects of the Stare aren’t permanent, as far as we know.”
 
Most spells have reverse spells, so they’re not that big a deal.
 
 
@Zincy  
Well math doesn’t lie, but I’d basically have to review every episode to really get specific with the math, and I don’t want to do that.
Millennial Dan
Artist -

@Techy Pony  
I thought of the chicken thing, but hey, it was a stressful situation and she was trying to take care of the kids. It was… semi-dire, a chaotic situation that needed quick looking after. More or less.
 
Anyway, that’s the exception. The other situations were pretty serious. And at least the effects of the Stare aren’t permanent, as far as we know.
Techy Pony

@Millennial Dan  
If I were to calculate the ratio of times Twi has used magic as the solution to the number of episodes Twi was the one coming up with the solution, I would bet you that it would be about the same if not less than the ratio of times Fluttershy has used the stare as a major part of the solution to the number of episodes where Fluttershy played any descent role in the solution.
 
I say ratio because Twilight is the focus most the time. If Twilight uses magic as the solution in 10 episodes but comes up with some solution in 30 and Fluttershy uses the stare in 3 episodes but has only been a reasonable part of the solution in 9 episodes, then Twilight is no more worth criticizing.
 
“It’s a similar concept to Twilight’s brainwashing magic, which is precisely why Fluttershy says she prefers not to use it. Twilight has no such ethical qualms about this.”
 
She used the stare to make chicken go into (or was it come out of?) their chicken coop. She clearly doesn’t use it in “dire situations” only and has no ethical qualms with it. The writers pulled that from their ass.
Millennial Dan
Artist -

@Techy Pony  
I don’t. I have also critiqued the writing when Pinkie is portrayed like a total nincompoop such as in WA, Dash as an obnoxious self-obsessed egomaniac in MMDW, and even Fluttershy as she was done up in PYHD.
 
By the way though, Fluttershy doesn’t overuse her stare. It’s a similar concept to Twilight’s brainwashing magic, which is precisely why Fluttershy says she prefers not to use it. Twilight has no such ethical qualms about this.