Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!
Description
My english is very very very very bad, but my duty spread the truth while you can read it))
Source
not provided yet
Rarity uses gems to decorate clothing. Pinkie bakes cakes to spread joy.
Did you even watch the show?
She provides a glimmer of hope to the disaffected
Fight fight fight!
Relax man, you’re not the first trolling with content about communism.
Don’t take it so serious.
History is not science. Anyway what you need? Proof conspiracy Hitler and Churchill? Come here and see the millions of tombstones my people who fell in the war. What about Overlord operation? Mmm, you’re just in time! Can you perform this after the war? Soviet Union feel self good without allied help. Damn hypocrites. Vengeance for my Soviet country is near.
It’s a joke. But by half. Believe in it.
Edited
Nah, this is a completely joke post. No serious arguments or historical evidence.
Good bait anyway.
They can earn according to they talents anyway. Pinkie just help to shes relatives, and you totaly miss meaning of Rar’s cutiemark.
“What does Celestia’s cutie mark”
Like miss Celestia and other too. You see, but not think.
“For one thing, they seem to possess the authority to sentence criminals to punishments on the spot, and nobody questions it at all.”
Well what about school of friendship when this has closed by advice or same Flim and Flam who’s really criminal elements? What princesses doing with they? Nothing or nothing?
“to sentence criminals to punishments on the spot”
Because they national danger. In time of war same criminals just shoot without court.
“Are you even watching the same show? Zecora isn’t the head of this place (especially considering it’s a flashback episode), and she isn’t in any control over healthcare industries, potions or not:”
“In one of ep Zecora heal in the hospital (she into tree).”
I mean when she sick “Swamp Fever”, another heal she in hospital.
“Where’s the evidence that Rarity’s Boutiques are actually owned by the state?”
Where’s the evidence that Rarity’s Boutiques are actually owned by she self?
Edited
What does Rarity’s special talent (finding gems) inherently have to do with what she does for a living? Pinkie Pie’s ability to spread joy and laughter, have anything to do with baking?
nothing
What does Celestia’s cutie mark that relates to the sun inherently have to do with running a country, being a leader? Nothing.
What does Starlight’s cutie mark inherently have to do with what she does throughout, whether it’d be her being a cult leader, her being a guidance counselor, or Headmare?
There’s multiple examples of cutie marks not inherently denoting what jobs they actually do, throughout.
Hmm… [citation needed]
For one thing, they seem to possess the authority to sentence criminals to punishments on the spot, and nobody questions it at all.
Are you saying this applies very well under Celestia’s rule? Because uh… well, ponies are quite ignorant in regards to other races. I mean, they know little about dragons, and Twilight (mistakenly) thought Griffonstone wasn’t a total dump, in the episode of The Lost Treasure of Griffonstone.
(in other words, not really, no)
Are you even watching the same show? Zecora isn’t the head of this place (especially considering it’s a flashback episode), and she isn’t in any control over healthcare industries, potions or not:
your current filter.In addition, “free education?” Then why did nopony call BS on Flim and Flam charging bits for charging people in Friendship University, as in “no place I’ve ever seen/heard of does anything like this”? As a matter of fact, explain Flim and Flam in general. Are they actually government stooges?
Where’s the evidence that Rarity’s Boutiques are actually owned by the state?
I made really awesome joke, because i am an addict. That post is a joke but at the same time not a joke.
Of course some elements hint at the capitalist society (more US society, look at the flag, lol), but trying to invent this society more ideal, the writer’s don’t think about make from Equestria many socialism elements than anything else.
“Monarchs are shown giving speeches, doing paperwork, giving advice, hosting important events, and commanding the military.”
It’s all, but society very organized as well. State has no military, it’s just guards. Military get from civilians, if begin a total war (like war with king Sombra)
“Why would a socialist society even have monarchs in the first place?”
Because they can. It like peaceful transition to socialism (not like in Russia), because society enough on your own and actually not needed a state (1 cop in Manehattan, no guards in Ponyville, Celestia play only decorate role and control Sun or Moon not she’s exclusive privilege)
“Isn’t socialism supposed to be about equality?”
Of course not, communism not for that. What about socialism, it is when many classes (proletarians or peasants) oppress another “hight” classes (ex rulers, intelligentce). Then that classes are destroyed, society no need at state anymore. Of course that simple description except economics and foreign-policy (USSR lost in cold war because has many enemyes).
“Equestria’s “internationalism” could also be interpreted as imperialism; Equestria maintains a large sphere of influence outside its borders, deposes foreign leaders, and pressures other countries into adopting its way of life.”
Socialist camp can and needs to expand, because enemies anytime can destroy this society. And depose another authoritarian rulers. Left side it is not yours pacifist feminists clowns or something else. They warriers, who can bring peace and development on their bayonets
OP is more the joke than the post itself tbh.
I somehow get the impression OP isn’t in on the joke, though…
@Twiface
It’s almost as if Equestria had a feudal government structure combined with a capitalist culture.
Edited
Rewatch ‘Sweet and Elite’ and ‘Twilight Time’
You can. Its just my theory and observations, nothing more.)
The role family does play an important role, Celestia taught Twilight and knows who to send were to avert disaster ‘most of the time’. The royal’s control the sun and moon, Plus it does seem kinda of big that the ruling family controls the Equestrian military. Wonderbolts and all that. Yes, Communism can happen through weakening the state, but most forms of government can spring up from a weak state.
The royals are definitely not complete dictators or anything, but they do have a great deal of power. I mean, I really doubt anyone is going to argue if Celestia and Luna decide to come out of retirement in 50 years and take over again, ya know?
I tend to consider them Benevolent Dictators.
Edited
“Equestria has a royal guard and military forces which go to the ruling Alicorn for orders.”
Yes, but royal family and guards dont play very important pole. It’s like “development socialism” and then state or kingdom almost die. To communism come through weakening of the state.
@Background Pony #BB79
“and Zecora just do things for free because it’s just Zecora, right?”
In one of ep Zecora heal in the hospital (she into tree).
“Filty Rich”
But social differentiation is really small.
@LemonDrop
Like democracy or absolutely monarchy. In real life can stand only hybrid dictatures who are US colonies. My country become another colony at 1991 year.
Edited
I..guess this is comparing Starlight to Communism? She wasn’t communist ya know, she was just a dictator who wanted equality for all, that is not communism.
Edited
Yes, it is.