Can we just agree that she was gone for a long time before Faust found her and that the personality we knew her by has been basically eroded away by Mother-Daughter Time? And regular Time time?
@Bronitarian
…I don’t see how I contradicted myself.
Just because she doesn’t say that she only found Celestia recently doesn’t mean that she hasn’t. Yeah, she does say that she found Celestia recently, but she doesn’t directly deny it either.
By that logic, I could say you’re saying bullshit too, because she’s not directly saying that Celestia’s been with her for a while.
“Second, Fausticorn said that during her travels, she found Celestia, which implies that she only recently found her.”
“I’m not making stuff up, I’m drawing my conclusions from the information I’ve been given.”
My question. :So where does she say she only found celestia recently?
Your response.
“It doesn’t say it, but it’s not denied either. She said “I happened across a curious thing during my Travels. I found your sister”. It doesn’t say that she recently found her, but it doesn’t say “Your sister is with me” or anything else that would imply that she was with her for a long period of time.”
@Bronitarian
>Fausticorn flat out says plain as day
…Not really…
I mean, if she found Celestia, wouldn’t she want Luna to at least know about it? Why couldn’t she have sent Celestia back immediately?
>Also you drawing your conclusions from information you’ve been given is by yout own admission false.
…Stop putting words in my mouth.
@441TheSecond
Fausticorn flat out says plain as day that celestia has been traveling with her for eons. So the thing where there were no implications of her being with her mom a long time,isnt true.
Also you drawing your conclusions from information you’ve been given is by yout own admission false.
@Bronitarian
It doesn’t say it, but it’s not denied either. She said “I happened across a curious thing during my Travels. I found your sister”. It doesn’t say that she recently found her, but it doesn’t say “Your sister is with me” or anything else that would imply that she was with her for a long period of time.
(Also, I cannot shake the feeling that this is not Celestia, benevolent ruler of Equestria, but Mouthpiecelestia, the pony that was used as a cheap mouthpiece for one of the stupidest “movements” I have ever seen in my entire life.
I was talking about the brainwashing stuff because of thd folks below your post. Sorry about the confusion there.
That second part of your reply though is unfounded. Nothing in what fausticorn said implies she only found her recently, nor that she was spending all that time alone and immobilized so that all she could do was think. You’re just making stuff up to make this darker then kt is.
@Bronitarian
First, I never said anything about brainwashing.
Second, Fausticorn said that during her travels, she found Celestia, which implies that she only recently found her.
Third… I don’t get why even tie this to the old Molestia continuity. I get having vague references to it, but to outright say “this is the real Molestia, and she spent eons with nothing but her own voice to hear”. You could have simply have had a soft reboot where Celestia was always normal, instead, it creates an uneasy atmosphere.
I mean, what about the rest of the population? Won’t Twilight be disappointed that her partner no longer has any sexual or even romantic urges towards her? Won’t her subjects confuse her when they think of her as a sexual beast?
@441TheSecond
Seems like a lot of hubbub over nothing if you ask me. Considering she was with her mother the whole or most of thr time, traveling with her and spending time with her in a way she always wanted but never got to, I wouldn’t consider it a banishing as much as a leave of absence. Luna spent 1000 years confined to a single place, possible unable to move or speak or anything, and made to watch her home move and change without her every night, and for good reason thanks to her corruption. So maybe the two could be considered more or less even now.
And besides, calling it brainwashing is like saying someone got brainwashed because they used to love going out, partying, and getting wasted every night in their college years, but 20 years later no longer do thst sort kf thing. Its called change, and it happens when people spend a long time existing.
If this was a whole new continuity, there’d be no problem, but considering that this Celestia is intended to be Molestia… Yeah… This is kinda creepy. Also, everytime I see her I think of PinkiePony’s stupid fucking bullshit, so thanks for tainting my favorite character, rich.
Also, she seems rather calm for somepony who was banished for fucking eons to dimensions beyond, what, Luna gets all the sympathy, yet Celestia is banished for so long that she completely forgets even her own personality and nobody says a thing?
Y’know, this strip has the potential to get really dark now. I mean Molestia has essentially been brainwashed by the public decency brigade into being a “Good Girl”. That’s some 1984 style re-education sh*t right there.
@Techy Pony
Not much chance of that, he’s done with her, be it that he got tired of her himself and the idiots who complained theres little to no chance of Molestia returning. Though I do hope she still loves Twilight.
Hopefully, Pinkie will soon be thrown in jail for that deportation stunt she tried to pull.
Hey, weren’t you killed by that Pinkie bitch and her SJW?
You have to be careful now, they’re watching us, ready to strike on any kind of ‘bullshit’ they believe.
It’s hard for some to move on. Eventually they will though. Eventually…
…I don’t see how I contradicted myself.
Just because she doesn’t say that she only found Celestia recently doesn’t mean that she hasn’t. Yeah, she does say that she found Celestia recently, but she doesn’t directly deny it either.
By that logic, I could say you’re saying bullshit too, because she’s not directly saying that Celestia’s been with her for a while.
“…Stop putting words in my mouth.”
//////
“Second, Fausticorn said that during her travels, she found Celestia, which implies that she only recently found her.”
“I’m not making stuff up, I’m drawing my conclusions from the information I’ve been given.”
My question. :So where does she say she only found celestia recently?
Your response.
“It doesn’t say it, but it’s not denied either. She said “I happened across a curious thing during my Travels. I found your sister”. It doesn’t say that she recently found her, but it doesn’t say “Your sister is with me” or anything else that would imply that she was with her for a long period of time.”
Last panel
This entire comic
I think it’s pretty clear Celestia has been gone for eons.
>Fausticorn flat out says plain as day
…Not really…
I mean, if she found Celestia, wouldn’t she want Luna to at least know about it? Why couldn’t she have sent Celestia back immediately?
>Also you drawing your conclusions from information you’ve been given is by yout own admission false.
…Stop putting words in my mouth.
Fausticorn flat out says plain as day that celestia has been traveling with her for eons. So the thing where there were no implications of her being with her mom a long time,isnt true.
Also you drawing your conclusions from information you’ve been given is by yout own admission false.
It doesn’t say it, but it’s not denied either. She said “I happened across a curious thing during my Travels. I found your sister”. It doesn’t say that she recently found her, but it doesn’t say “Your sister is with me” or anything else that would imply that she was with her for a long period of time.
(Also, I cannot shake the feeling that this is not Celestia, benevolent ruler of Equestria, but Mouthpiecelestia, the pony that was used as a cheap mouthpiece for one of the stupidest “movements” I have ever seen in my entire life.
My hatred for DWM doesn’t know bounds)
So where does she say she only found celestia recently?
I’m not making stuff up, I’m drawing my conclusions from the information I’ve been given.
Same thing with Luna in the moon, in fact.
I was talking about the brainwashing stuff because of thd folks below your post. Sorry about the confusion there.
That second part of your reply though is unfounded. Nothing in what fausticorn said implies she only found her recently, nor that she was spending all that time alone and immobilized so that all she could do was think. You’re just making stuff up to make this darker then kt is.
First, I never said anything about brainwashing.
Second, Fausticorn said that during her travels, she found Celestia, which implies that she only recently found her.
Third… I don’t get why even tie this to the old Molestia continuity. I get having vague references to it, but to outright say “this is the real Molestia, and she spent eons with nothing but her own voice to hear”. You could have simply have had a soft reboot where Celestia was always normal, instead, it creates an uneasy atmosphere.
I mean, what about the rest of the population? Won’t Twilight be disappointed that her partner no longer has any sexual or even romantic urges towards her? Won’t her subjects confuse her when they think of her as a sexual beast?
Seems like a lot of hubbub over nothing if you ask me. Considering she was with her mother the whole or most of thr time, traveling with her and spending time with her in a way she always wanted but never got to, I wouldn’t consider it a banishing as much as a leave of absence. Luna spent 1000 years confined to a single place, possible unable to move or speak or anything, and made to watch her home move and change without her every night, and for good reason thanks to her corruption. So maybe the two could be considered more or less even now.
And besides, calling it brainwashing is like saying someone got brainwashed because they used to love going out, partying, and getting wasted every night in their college years, but 20 years later no longer do thst sort kf thing. Its called change, and it happens when people spend a long time existing.
Yyyyeah…
If this was a whole new continuity, there’d be no problem, but considering that this Celestia is intended to be Molestia… Yeah… This is kinda creepy. Also, everytime I see her I think of PinkiePony’s stupid fucking bullshit, so thanks for tainting my favorite character, rich.
Also, she seems rather calm for somepony who was banished for fucking eons to dimensions beyond, what, Luna gets all the sympathy, yet Celestia is banished for so long that she completely forgets even her own personality and nobody says a thing?
Not much chance of that, he’s done with her, be it that he got tired of her himself and the idiots who complained theres little to no chance of Molestia returning. Though I do hope she still loves Twilight.
Maybe remembrance will bring with it the emotions and personality of the past~
Forgot about that…this might be an interesting development.