hey,josh is a good guy.why all the arrows are pointed to him?

@Background Pony #6C45  
He’s stolen more than three of Doug’s jokes word for word actually. I gave him a chance because my brother watched him and find Josh annoying. You kinda just sound like your a fan making excuses for Josh to be honest.

@Background Pony #FD16  
Y’know, I don’t really think he’s stolen that much from Nostalgia Critic. Maybe a few jokes (Everyone’s done the Of Course thing at least once), and definitely the style as well, but other than that…not much, really. Heck, the Nostalgia Critic’s style could be considered a ripoff of MST3K with more emphasis on reviewing than riffing (though he has put more and more emphasis on reviewing as time went on). Also, reviewing isn’t all he does. He also makes countdowns, he has some (unfinished) let’s plays on his channel, and he even does brass quintet remixes of video game songs.
 
*Backs away slowly to keep from being called a fanboy*

@Mayojar77  
Fluttershy wasn’t cute in Putting Your Hoof Down. At least, none when she was being unreasonably cruel to everypony.

I honestly wasn’t that bothered by Pinkie in the new episode. I suppose it would’ve been nicer if she apologized though.

@Mayojar77  
you’re an idiot if you think she was willing

@Mayojar77
 
How would you expect someone with social anxiety to act?

@Background Pony #FD16
 
Their probably funnier than ‘you’.

All criticism of the poster and the originality of his other creations aside (where they belong), he is right in his answer.
 
Yes, Pinkie knows about Fluttershy’s hyper-delicate sensitivity and was able to take it into account, when she was pranking with Rainbow Dash in Griffon the Brush-off, but that’s entirely realistic. People are not perfectly, logically consistent across all situations and all days of their life. It’s entirely believable that she would understand a prank - which is intended to cause minor upset or fright - would be too much, but not notice the unintentional effect of her rambling on Fluttershy.

@PonyPon  
Hurricane Fluttershy.
 
Although, of course, there would not have been a drought, because Cloudsdale would just have gotten the water on another day and/or from somewhere else. The highly contrived situation that made Fluttershy’s participation necessary would just have prevented Ponyville from supplying the water.

@Mayojar77  
What episode was that?

When Fluttershy acts like a jackass without realizing it, it’s cute, but when Pinkie does it, it’s wrong? Need I remind you Fluttershy was perfectly willing to cause a drought because of her social anxiety.

@Captain L  
It would actually be very fitting if Josh ended up on TGWTG’s considering that the site’s a haven for unfunny Internet “critics”.

@Background Pony #FD16  
It’s worth noting that he had a conversation with Doug, who liked the video he was shown.

@Background Pony #FD16  
So just another day on the “’net after the .com crash”? Got it, thanks.

@Neo987  
An unfunny reviewer who steals jokes from the Nostalgia Critic due to his lack of creative skill, he also tries to replicate Doug’s cringeworthy skits un-ironically. Why should you care? I can’t think a reason…

What a dickish way to make a reply.

As right as he is, who is he and why should I care?

It’s true, Josh is still an unfunny hack though.

They went a bit overboard with the joke, but it wasn’t enough to detract from the enjoyment for me.

“Don’t write it off,” “Serious issue”?  
More like lack of character knowledge on this guys part…  
Kudos josh.

I know people think some only have a problem cuz it was Shy, and they’re probably a little right.
 
But it was still too much, as in-character as it was.

Now I’m really glad I’m subscribed to him on youtube.

He forget a friend in deed but otherwise he is right