@Amm  
Not to mention she waved to some residents… Almost like she already knew them…
 
Also… Who looks for logic in a music number of a musical?

@Derpyfan  
She wasn’t. It was a singing lesson that included specific locations to help illustrate different points.

@Amm  
Explain why she had to be introduced to Ponyville then, because if she was Starlight’s kid she would have already been there before.

@Ponysa  
So the reason Jim thinks she isn’t their daughter is because “But if Luster was related to the Headmare and Vice-Headmare of the School of Friendship, how could she be so condescending about friendship?”… but she’s the student of the Princess of Friendship, the same conundrum applies. So Big Jim’s basis is flawed and all we have left is Haber’s intent.

@UserAccount  
So… In your headcanon universe, Starlight married Trixie and you, and Luster Dawn is someone else’s daughter? Okay… Not sure how that works, but okay… Schrödinger’s continuity is in effect anyways.
 
@hironakamura  
Thank you for proving my point on Word of God sometimes being wrong.

@hironakamura  
No, me.

@UserAccount  
I will marry Trixie. That’s canon.

@hironakamura  
No, Jim outranks him and Starburst can never be canon!!! SHE MUST MARRY TRIXIE!!!!

@Ponysa  
I would go with the guy who wrote the episode. It was his vision. Jim’s the guy that thinks Spike and Twilight are the same age.

@Edhelistar  
It’s canon until hasbro says otherwise

@Ponysa  
I knew it!

@Edhelistar  

 
According to Big Jim, Josh says yes to Luster being Starlight & Sunburst’s daughter, but he (Jim) still is leaving up to the fans to decide :D  

@Derpyfan  
Hasbro outranks them all. And anything said below Hasbro, isn’t canon. 😊

@Edhelistar  
Here’s how I see it: Jim outranks him so what he says goes in situations like this.

@Background Pony #C589  
I wonder, though: Has anyone asked Josh Haber? Y’know, the one who wrote the episode…

@Background Pony #F735  
To mess with the fans of course. But! Word of God might be wrong too. I remember this one time Meghan McCarthy said “Twilight won’t outlive her friends”…

@Sff  
Well that’s just odd. Why on earth did they make her look so much like them then? Even down to the cutie mark?

Hey if it makes the Starburst shippers feel any better, who knows? They might have kids still! It’s just not Luster! ;)

@Sff  
Oh well, it was a nice hypothesis.

Sure why not

@Sff  
What did I tell you guys?

Just got debunked, would’ve been cool though  
https://twitter.com/TheBiggestJim/status/1183194179863629824

@Edhelistar  
Since he said so apparently.

@ThatGreyPeanut  
Woah, woah, woah! Since when!?