The 2018 Community Collab has begun! Announcing round two of our annual community collaboration group picture! More information here

Unpopular opinion time

Started by Itsthinking Posted Login to subscribe to responses
Japanese Teeth's avatar
Posts: 118
Japanese Teeth
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012

@GargantuanBass

Seriously, the thing that irks me most about the WUB WUB WUB stuff is that every time she’s shown playing music it doesn’t resemble dubstep at all

Also, an opinion about fan works: I think a lot of them take the easy way out in regard to "feels" by simply dumping a character in a situation and relying on a pre-existing attachment to the character to provide the emotion rather than giving any in-work reason for it.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Whatevs's avatar
Posts: 30882
Whatevs
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012
Thread Starter - The great GamerGate discussion.

Arch-Rarifag
Oh I have another unpopular opinion.

When it comes to the content of her character (both in a story sense and moral sense) twilight is highly unremarkable.

The only thing special about her is her magic which serves to dilute her rather than add to.

The other ponies don’t have superpowers and yet remain just as brave and steadfast in the face of danger.

This is really the reason Twilicorn rubs me the wrong way and in general having each finale and premier focus on her is indulging on a character that is not noteworthy at all.

That’s me.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Posts: 240
Rainbow Dash
@Whatevs
Is that really relevant when discussing how good writers are?

The point of fanfiction is to take the characters and other things you enjoy in the show and put them into new scenarios, new circumstances, ect. Essentially it is to entertain and explore new ideas and concepts, while retaining things you are familar with.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Whatevs's avatar
Posts: 30882
Whatevs
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012
Thread Starter - The great GamerGate discussion.

Arch-Rarifag
@Rainbow Dash
World building is really just creating a setting. It’s detail work.

I know there’s more to it and it has it’s own challenges but character is far more complex.

Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Japanese Teeth's avatar
Posts: 118
Japanese Teeth
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012

@Rainbow Dash

Related: I think a lot of fanfic authors go overboard on the "introducing new elements" thing and don’t keep enough of an attachment to the show. I tend to enjoy fanfic far more when there are only one or two new factors and then seeing how those factors influence the characters. When a fic starts off with a cast of OCs in a setting that’s never been seen in the show, and is about some aspect of the cosmology that the author made up, it rarely holds my interest no matter how well written it is.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Whatevs's avatar
Posts: 30882
Whatevs
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012
Thread Starter - The great GamerGate discussion.

Arch-Rarifag
@Rainbow Dash
If they are writing about preset characters… Then their talent is limited compared to the people who made those characters.

Especially given the restraints that others have posited in this thread.

Canon > fanon.
That isn’t to say that fanon is all garbage but the trueborn son is always regarded better than the bastard child.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Ebalosus's avatar
Posts: 3094
Ebalosus
Ruby
Bronze Bit
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012
Bronze Patron
Happy Derpy!

Praise RNGesus
@Itsthinking

You get what I’m saying though? Whenever the show does something that some people don’t like, Faust’s name is always invoked to say how much the show now sucks with her no longer at the helm.

Distressingly, a lot of reasonable people do this too, not just trolls. CR, for example, the person whom got me to finally watch the show, has now become one of those people whom praise Faust in one hand while bashing the current show makers and those whom disagree with him in the other.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Splitframe's avatar
Posts: 13
Splitframe
I don’t know if the opinion is unpopular, but I would
like the show to transit from a slice of life setting
to a series with a goal.

Not that I don’t like slice of life and one episode
stories, but it grows rather old.

I’d like to have a goal or thread established at the
beginning and then worked on that on every episode.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Itsthinking's avatar
Posts: 12373
Itsthinking
Sapphire
Silver Bit
Birthday Cake - Celebrated MLP's 7th birthday
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - Uploader of 10+ images with 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Princess Ember - Derpi Supporter
Not a Llama - Happy April Fools Day!
An Artist Who Rocks - 100+ images under their artist tag
Friendship, Art, and Magic - Celebrated Derpibooru's five year anniversary with friends.
A Perfectly Normal Pony - <Itsthinking> FUCKING TUMBLR
Artist
Thread Starter - Unpopular opinion time
Happy Derpy!
Silver Patron

Site Assistant
🅱
@Ebalosus
The funny thing is that Rob Renzetti is actually the person who was the showrunner most of the time, he did day to day show things.

So when people say the show sucks without Faust, it’s actually Renzetti they want.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Posts: 240
Rainbow Dash
@Whatevs
My ultimate pet-peeve with canon is not anything in the canon itself. It is the people who automatically declare it to be superior. "Canon > Fanon" has never rubbed me the right way, Sorry.

Anyway, I need to return to FIMfiction to continue reading.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Splitframe's avatar
Posts: 13
Splitframe
@Takuto_Devastated


hmmm hnnnn mmmmh

I don’t know, S3 puts in a bit of general progress
like Dash and the Wonderbolts or Discord… and of course
the start and finale, but I meant something more specific.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
someguy111's avatar
Posts: 3253
someguy111
I got to this thread pretty late but…
I HATED Wonderbolts Academy and drill sergeant Spitfire
I HATED Read it and Weep
Mare Do Well wasn’t as bad as people say
I don’t like some of the songs
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
GargantuanBass's avatar
Posts: 640
GargantuanBass
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012
Thread Starter - Vent thread

I think that "True True Friend" is the worst song of the series. The lyrics are just so mind-numbingly simple.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
MadBrony's avatar
Posts: 288
MadBrony
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - 10+ uploads with over 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Magnificent Metadata Maniac - #1 Assistant

I like Dragon Quest.
I don’t care if Angel treated bad Fluttershy.
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Ebalosus's avatar
Posts: 3094
Ebalosus
Ruby
Bronze Bit
The End wasn't The End - Found a new home after the great exodus of 2012
Bronze Patron
Happy Derpy!

Praise RNGesus
@Itsthinking

Touché

@Whatevs

Chad Rocco from TGWTG. If you follow him on twitter and/or tumbler, you’ll find out that he’s turned into one of those fans
Posted Report
LinkQuoteReply
Thank you to our advertisers for supporting Derpibooru
"Curing cancer, one protein at a time.

Derpibooru costs $25 a day. Help keep the site up - click here to donate and hide ads on the site

Syntax quick reference: *bold* _italic_ [spoiler]hide text[/spoiler] @code@ +underline+ -strike- ^sup^ ~sub~