@Prof.NightJack  
Still, seeing reason help to put thing in right context, and helps to understand character. It’s nothing like “Ololo, just an excuse, evil!” or “Twilight justifies evil meme”, it’s not nullifies the guilt. But it help to understand, and the first step to reconciliation, if both parties accept their faults. We already know RD’s reasons, I just pointed out Gilda’s reasons.

@Background Pony #1605  
You are not one to talk about black and white logic, it pointed out how Pinkie has a bad part to how she acts and just because he said more bad about Gilda you say he’s angelized Pinkie, that’s not angelizing her when he pointed out something nagative about her.

What do I think will happen?
 
Drama. Loads and loads of it. Both in the show and from the fans.

@Millennial Dan  
>No excuse  
>Implying it was just an excuse and not part of reason  
>Black & white logic  
And what’s your point, exactly? So, you angelized Pinkie and demonized Gilda, ignoring RD&Gilda’s relationship. And what comes from that? Gilda should be guillotined or what?

@Background Pony #1605  
Jealousy is no excuse. Pinkie can be a nuisance, but in that episode, she was able to acknowledge that. That doesn’t make her a terrible person, just a little immature.
 
Gilda, by contrast, was not just guilty of a horrible attitude, she’s also a social deviant who steals things and bullies people. She was absolutely positively without question to blame for what happened.

@Background Pony #C402  
And I thought this kind of stupid was going away…

@CrassMetalHead  
>logic  
>gilda fanboys
 
pick one

@avalon487  
“Betrayed” is a bit strong word, don’t you think? And RD&Gilda isn’t the only ones to blame; Pinkie Pie also somewhat fiddled through the back door.
 
@NoodleNugget  
I think much of her anger originated from jealousy.

Gilda felt betrayed by rainbow dash and goes back to griffonstone breeding distrust between the griffons  
queue episode

Intensifying intensifies
 
Gilda? Gilda.
 
If the lost treasure turns out to be friendship I’m going to start hurling random passerby into a woodchipper.

@avalon487  
What fucking logic is this.

Something tells me I gotta update the 1 Year Image I had.
 
Especially if they nod to Gilda in a way that makes it seem like such little time had passed.

@MadBrony  
Nicholson: You Can’t Handle the Truth!

@avalon487  
I don’t think you knew what “betrayed” means.

@avalon487  

@Background Pony #C402  
>denying the truth

@MadVillan  
She never abandoned her. Dash gave her a choice to treat her new friends better or leave, and Gilda chose to leave.

@avalon487  
Keep telling yourself that.

GILDA CONFIRMED

@avalon487  
I know that  
I meant pinkie did make fluttershy cry too.

@Millennial Dan
 
Dash was responsible for the pranks at the party, deliberately led her into each one, then played it off as “ dumb luck.” She betrayed Gilda.

One way or another, Dash didn’t do anything wrong in that episode. Gilda was entirely to blame, and she’s the one that had better be doing a lot of apologizing if she’s going to start hanging around again.

@C Money  
Pinkie did worst to her

@Prof.NightJack  
Bro. She made Fluttershy cry. That is punishable by dungeon in their place of exile!

@C Money  
For get that, she didn’t enjoy Pinkie party! >:(