Adagio needs an umbrella.

Well, neither will the reformed villains like Starlight, Discord, etc., I mean they’ll both remain on the loose, alive and evil

Chrysalis is Negan because neither of them will ever die.

@Background Pony #0B7C  
I chose Sombra as Negan because he fits Negan’s dark trait. Tirek would make a good Negan because their both strong badasses but in my opinion Sombra is better because he is a dark character, so is Negan. Which is why I prefer Sombra as Negan over Tirek.

@Background Pony #DDA0  
Characters in both The Walking Dead and My Little Pony have similar traits. Starlight Glimmer is related to The Governor because both were powerful rulers who were sought out as masiahs until they showed their true colors and lost everything. As for Adagio, she’s more up Negan’s ally. She is cunning and unpredictable as well as manipulative and doesn’t care what happens to anyone not in their league unless you give them what they want. And that’s what makes both characters a badass. Oh, and it would be cool if Sombra became Negan but in my opinion Tirek would be a better Negan.

@toxicrystal  
I know it’s just a headcanon, and I explained why (in my opinion) it’s bad, especially if you actually like dazzlings

@Mit boy  
The keyword there is “headcanon”. It’s my idea, not what would happen. Unless I actually claim that my headcanon is canon, there’s really no reason to be this upset over it.  
You’re acting like I just said utter heresy or something.

@Background Pony #0B7C  
What?! I would love to see siren redemption. That guy just have head canon that sirens is not the girls and when gems were destroyed sirens died! And now he want redemption of the girls that even didn’t made anything wrong! That what I don’t like. I’m talking about toxic crystal btw

@Mit boy  
I have to agree with DDA0 on this one. People like you thought villains like Discord or Trixie couldn’t be redeemed of their actions, but they did. Maybe the sirens can be redeemed of their actions and they can know what it takes to be on the good side. Say all you want mit boy, in the future you may be wrong (this is not a hate comment, its my opinion against your claim).

@Background Pony #DDA0  
I want their redemption in canon but that’s unlikely

@Mit boy  
You say that the sirens redemption story is nothing but fanfic. It could happen in the future Equestria Girls movies.

@Background Pony #0D68  
I… don’t know what?

@Mit boy  
You don’t know that. The sirens can come back in the near future and be redemed of their actions. Sure some villains like Bowser can help their arch enemies at times so long as they keep their role as the villain while other villains like The Governor try to redeem their actions so long as they are away from others only to become evil again and kill people, but it doesn’t mean they can’t show emotion and realize what they did was wrong. You may say that didn’t work well with The Governor, but the zombie apocalypse has a different way of effecting people than Equestria and Human Equestria do. The fanfics are only signs of the future you aqua dodo, it may not happen but we can take the chance. I’ve even written my own version of The Dazzlings redemption, and its more of a Super Paper Mario/Lord of the rings story.

@toxicrystal  
Point taken.

@Joseph Raszagal  
Basically. I’m casting Sombra as Negan for MLP TWD. If you thought Sweetie Belle getting torn apart was bad, just wait when Sombra beats Dr Hooves to death with Lucille.

@toxicrystal  
It means their redemption potential that we know from fanfiction is dead and Your redemption idea is too similar to Sunset’s and it still means that sirens are dead.  
Usually in fanfiction, Sunset and Mane5 have to convince Sirens to JUST TAKE their help first (Sonata usually easiest one and Adagio is the hardest). And I like that because it makes sirens not dead.

@Joseph Raszagal  
Oi, spoiler your stuff. Das REALLY new.

@Mit boy  
But here’s the thing: it isn’t dead. Who else actually knows other than the Sirens that the pendants were the real evil?  
Nobody. To everyone else, the Sirens were malicious out of their own free will. The redemption quality still comes in, as the Sirens realize they caused a ton of shit and they’re gonna try to fix it.  
At least, I know Sonata will try and fix it.

@Background Pony #DDA0
 
So Sweetie Belle gets torn apart while Dr. Hooves stares in shock, powerless to help… Well, that’s pleasant to imagine.
 
Also, I always knew Diamond Tiara would kill Silver Spoon somehow.

@toxicrystal  
No, this is not a cool theory. It means that Sirens that we know, and their redemption potential (that we know from fanfiction) is dead.

@toxicrystal  
In the first Equestria Girls, Sunset Shimmer was incredibly unlikable due to her cliche bitchy like attitude and braindead plan. If Rainbow Rocks didn’t exist, she would have continued to be the worst character in MLP history forever. As for Andrea in the tv show, she had that bitchy attitude that Sunset had. That’s why I put Sunset as Andrea. I was going to Bon Bon as Andrea but I decided against it. I put my oc villain character as The Governor because he shares the same trait as The Governor does. Care to hear me explain it? Or not?

@Background Pony #DDA0  
One problem:  
Sunset Shimmer is actually a good character. Andrea is not.

@Background Pony #DDA0
 
@toxicrystal  
Sorry about that, I wasn’t done yet. Anyways,
 
Doctor Hooves: Glenn  
Scootaloo: Carl  
Rainbow Dash: Daryl  
Applejack: Maggie  
Aria: Michonne  
Gilda: Merle  
Undecided: The Governor  
Spike: Hershel  
Fluttershy: Carol  
Bulk Biceps: Abraham  
Applebloom: Beth  
Shining Armor: Tyreese  
Zecora: Morgan  
Lyra: Amy  
Undecided: Morales  
Twilight’s dad: Jim  
The twelfth Doctor Hooves: Dr. Jenner  
Big Mac: T-Dog  
Undecided: Sophia  
Rarity’s father: Otis  
Undecided: Dave  
Snails: Randall  
Undecided: Axel  
Bab Seed: Martinez  
The Human world Twilight: Milton  
Cadence: Sasha  
Undecided: Karen  
Derpy Hooves: Bob  
Diamond Tiara: Lizzie  
Silver Spoon: Mika  
Celestia: Lily  
Luna: Tara  
Undecided: Meghan  
Iron Will: Eugene  
Sonata Dusk: Rosita  
Garbule: Joe  
Ahuizotl: Gareth  
Changling: Martin  
Undecided: Gabriel  
Sweetie Belle: Noah  
Chrysalis: Dawn  
Carrot Cake: Judith  
Pinkie Pie: Aaron
 
I deeply apologize for the large spacing. My wifi connection was messing up and it made the website go bonkers. Also, I included only major and important minor characters that were important to the story. Feel free to share which characters would be which characters from The Walking Dead.

@toxicrystal  
If I would do a TWD reenactment by ponies, here’s what it will be:  
Twilight Sparkle: Rick  
Trixie Lulamoon: Shane  
Rarity: Lori  
Sunset Shimmer: Andrea  
Cheerliee: Dale

@Background Pony #DDA0  
Both have a “species” whose only goal in their life is to take something vital from you. They don’t care how it happens, and don’t pay attention to injury.