It’s not bad, but Shy looks like she’s somewhat emaciated.  
Then again, that could work for her.
 
Especially in the spring and summer, she may sometimes be so busy taking care of the animals that she could forget to feed herself, possibly even for several days at a time, if nobody comes to check on her.
 
Yeah, I think that would work for Flutters’ character.

I still like it.

@Vanilla Drop  
The way you put it, it seems like some artists I know feel more brooding than stubborn. But both sides must agree or come to a consensus for a healthy relationship. It is definitely important to know the tone behind the sentence.

@Brony kaiju soldier  
Mhmm.

@Azerdoe  
Me too. I think the world we live in now has everyone just hating on stuff for no good reason or just to shame others. That’s all I’m gonna say on the matter.

Rarity is hot, the rest…. Not my type

@Brony kaiju soldier  
Exactly. You get it at least dude. I appreciate your open mindedness and how well you accurately summed up the situation. All I want is for equal praise and criticism for everyone, but not fake accolades and harsh negativity.

@Azerdoe  
Let me just say I think vanilla drop has potential; their other art is actually really good, and, to be honest, the original piece wasn’t that bad, and some of us could’ve been a bit more sensitive with our critiques. As stated in honest apple, brutal honesty isn’t always the best.

@squirrle  
As they OP just stated to your own comment, they felt the comments directed towards them were more hurtful then constructive. Nobody should feel that way about sharing their works for people to enjoy. And before you say the inevitable, picture this. If you don’t like what you see and feel you’re about to say something that can or could come across as negative, just don’t say it and move on. Everyone has a right to both speak their mind and hold their tongue. Sometimes the latter is preferable.
 
Though I do understand your viewpoint. I just don’t agree with it.

@myszolowy  
In a ideal world? So in such a world there’s courtesy and respect but not in reality? That’s a sad point of view you have sir. But as I said before, just hold your tongue instead of spouting negativity towards the artists in question. Criticism is good, bullying and attacking them is not. And them drawing another comeback picture by emphasising big boobs is them calling out those who hurt them. Proving how shallow and one track minded they are. They should’ve free to express their art without people putting them down and forcing them to delete their art. I’ve had that happen to me many times when it came to my stories I wrote. People gave me “criticism” of my writing skills by saying things like “Just quit, you’ll never get better”. So helpful.
 
Bottom line, respect the creators of artworks despite your own opinion. You are free to like or dislike the art itself, but don’t take out your own feelings out on the artist themselves. That’s just common sense, something people here lack it seems.

They only one here that is messed up is Fluttershy. I have seen the other body types on people.

An improvement for a couple of them, but I can’t say the same for the rest.

They look all weird

@squirrle  
Yeah I did do that. And it is true my anatomy was off back then and I did improve from it. Though tbh some people who told me the anatomy was off could’ve maybe been a bit nicer, because holy shit I did not feel okay seeing so many people shit on something I had put much effort into making, even if it “looked ugly”. Some people did give me healthy, valid constructive criticism, but there were those who were rather harsh and I couldn’t really differentiate between the two after some time because I was just seeing every comment through a dark, negative lense

Creepy.

@Azerdoe  
No one attacked the artist. “We” said “the proporsion and faces are way off” the artis got mad, drew an picture trying to mock the haters “Since we only liked big breasted bimboes” witch ironicly enough got praise for beeing better but an a bit inmature. Said pic got flagged for hatespeech i belive.
 
Good to see its better now, still a bit uncany valley tough.

Good Pinkie.

@Cylindryk1  
Yes I agree but please keep it in English for other people, it might be impolite for others as they’re excluded from the conversation this way.

@myszolowy  
Spoko, nie ty jeden tak masz.  
Kiedyś krytyka oznaczała, ze po prostu musisz się bardziej przyłożyć, postarać.  
Teraz, nie wiem czemu, ale ludzie uznają krytykę wobec siebie jako “do niczego się nie nadajesz, umrzyj, itd.”.
 
A potem mamy takie “bezstresowo wychowane dzieci”….

Maybe I’m an old-timer but people these days think they have to rush in patronize and help someone no matter if they actually need that help or not.  
I’m actually impressed that the OP decided to improve his art and reupload it while still remembering the previous reception. That’s good and it wouldn’t happen if not people disliking the art.

@Azerdoe  
I’m sorry but we don’t live in an idealized world where effort is the only determinant of worthiness. If someone makes something and decides to publish it then that someone should be ready for people disliking that something.  
The OP never said anything about spitting venom or someone attacking him, especially as on this website such comments would most probably get deleted very fast by moderation. People probably just mostly disliked the picture drastically, some people said outwardly that they found this picture not appealing and that was probably enough to get on OPs feelings.  
And if someone can’t handle the critique then it’s his problem, not people disliking it. If you know that your art might not be liked then you should prepare for it.

Faces are nice good job on those for some reason I like Rarity’s the most

@Stitch  
Still AJ for me.

Those faces make me nope. Those are guy faces on girl bodies.

Face looks unique.