Viewing last 25 versions of comment by Alphamon_Ouryuken on image #15137

Alphamon_Ouryuken
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - Uploader of 10+ images with 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Artist -

Lord of the Empty Seat
"[@XD-385":](/15137#comment_8019447
)  
>>1742355t


 
First of all; there was never a line of dialogue that directly states or indicates that either of them are actual siblings with AJ's parents. So there is no continuity error as far as that's concerned.


 
Second of all; the Oranges could have simply been cousins of one of AJ's parents, they don't have to be direct siblings to be considered uncle and aunt. Plus there's the fact that we never see Granny's husband or Pear Butter's wife, so there's the possibility one of them (most likely Granny Smith's lover) was a part of the Orange family or maybe had a sibling that married into the Orange side of the family, thus making them a part of the Apple family.


 
Third of all; I recommend to that before you make baseless assumptions you do some proper analysis, considering the fact that I was able to come up with the above paragraph simply from doing a bit of research, it shouldn't be too hard for you to do the same instead of just pretending that is simple meme is what the episode was focused on.


 
Tell me, what exactly what did we know about AJ's parents before the Perfect Pear episode? I mean, besides them being dead?

_

 
*
Nothing._

*
 
Therefore there was nothing to truly retcon about them. The episode was made to explore the history of AJ's parents and give us info on exactly what their lives were like before they had children and passed on, not capitalise on a meme no one remembers.

"

 
[
I suggest you stop making up lies to justify your hatred of the series.":](https://www.fimfiction.net/group/198187/the-accusation-fic-collection/thread/378285/plot-concepts-that-bugged-you#comment/6639028)
No reason given
Edited by Alphamon_Ouryuken
Alphamon_Ouryuken
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - Uploader of 10+ images with 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Artist -

Lord of the Empty Seat
"@XD-385":/15137#comment_8019447
>>1742355t

First of all; there was never a line of dialogue that directly states or indicates that either of them are actual siblings with AJ's parents. So there is no continuity error as far as that's concerned.

Second of all; the Oranges could have simply been cousins of one of AJ's parents, they don't have to be direct siblings to be considered uncle and aunt. Plus there's the fact that we never see Granny's husband or Pear Butter's wife, so there's the possibility one of them (most likely Granny Smith's lover) was a part of the Orange family or maybe had a sibling that married into the Orange side of the family, thus making them a part of the Apple family.

Third of all; I recommend to that before you make baseless assumptions you do some proper analysis, considering the fact that I was able to come up with the above paragraph simply from doing a bit of research, it shouldn't be too hard for you to do the same instead of just pretending that is simple meme is what the episode was focused on.

Tell me, what exactly what did we know about AJ's parents before the Perfect Pear episode? I mean, besides them being dead?

_Nothing._

Therefore there was nothing to truly retcon. The episode was made to explore the history of AJ's parents and give us info on exactly what their lives were like before they had children and passed on, not capitalise on a meme no one remembers.

"I suggest you stop making up lies to justify your hatred of the series.":https://www.fimfiction.net/group/198187/the-accusation-fic-collection/thread/378285/plot-concepts-that-bugged-you#comment/6639028
No reason given
Edited by Alphamon_Ouryuken
Alphamon_Ouryuken
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - Uploader of 10+ images with 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Artist -

Lord of the Empty Seat
"@XD-385":/15137#comment_8019447
>>1742355t

First of all; there was never a line of dialogue that directly states or indicates that either of them are actual siblings with AJ's parents. So there is no continuity error as far as that's concerned.

Second of all; the Oranges could have simply been cousins of one of AJ's parents, they don't have to be direct siblings to be considered uncle and aunt. Plus there's the fact that we never see Granny's husband or Pear Butter's wife, so there's the possibility one of them (most likely Granny Smith's lover) was a part of the Orange family or maybe had a sibling that married into the Orange side of the family, thus making them a part of the Apple family.

Third of all; I recommend to that before you make baseless assumptions you do some proper analysis, considering the fact that I was able to come up with the above paragraph simply from doing a bit of research, it shouldn't be too hard for you to do the same instead of just pretending that is simple meme is what the episode was focused on.

Tell me, what exactly what did we know about AJ's parents before the Perfect Pear episode? I mean, besides them being dead?

_Nothing._

Therefore there was nothing to truly retcon. The episode was made to explore the history of AJ's parents and give us info on exactly what their lives were like before they had children and passed on, not capitalise on a meme no one remembers.

I suggest you stop making up lies to justify your hatred of the series.
No reason given
Edited by Alphamon_Ouryuken
Alphamon_Ouryuken
Perfect Pony Plot Provider - Uploader of 10+ images with 350 upvotes or more (Questionable/Explicit)
Artist -

Lord of the Empty Seat
"@XD-385":/15137#comment_8019447
>>1742355t

First of all; there was never a line of dialogue that directly states or indicates that either of them are actual siblings with AJ's parents. So there is no continuity error as far as that's concerned.

Second of all; the Oranges could have simply been cousins of one of AJ's parents, they don't have to be direct siblings to be considered uncle and aunt. Plus there's the fact that we never see Granny's husband or Pear Butter's wife, so there's the possibility one of them (most likely Granny Smith's lover) had a sibling that married into the Orange side of the family, thus making them a part of the Apple family.

Third of all; I recommend to that before you make baseless assumptions you do some proper analysis, considering the fact that I was able to come up with the above paragraph simply from doing a bit of research, it shouldn't be too hard for you to do the same instead of just pretending that is simple meme is what the episode was focused on.

Tell me, what exactly what did we know about AJ's parents before the Perfect Pear episode? I mean, besides them being dead?

_Nothing._

Therefore there was nothing to truly retcon. The episode was made to explore the history of AJ's parents and give us info on exactly what their lives were like before they had children and passed on, not capitalise on a meme no one remembers.

I suggest you stop making up lies to justify your hatred of the series.
No reason given
Edited by Alphamon_Ouryuken