Twilight:  
If she is going for good stats she would most likely have at least 1 or 2 legendaries on her team.  
I don’t know what her team would look like.
 
Rainbow Dash:  
She is looking for pokemon like  
Weavile  
Ninjask  
Jolteon  
Flygon  
Floatzel  
(Pokemon with agility or scary face)
 
Applejack:  
She probably hasn’t had any experience in Pokemon. I think she would go for the Pokemon with the biggest or the heaviest looking Pokemon.  
Nidoking  
Aggron  
Groudon  
Tyranitar  
Rhyperior  
Machamp
 
Fluttershy:  
She wants cute pokemon that are at least strong enough to protect her. The Pokemon evolve into their stronger forms:  
Eevee - Leafeon  
Togepi - Togekiss  
Riolu - Lucario  
Natu - Xatu  
Growlithe - Arcanine  
Aipom - Ambipom
 
Rarity:  
She would have shiny pokemon probably:  
Persian or Purugly (Shiny)  
Regice  
Ninetales (Shiny)  
Gardevoir  
Lapras (Shiny)  
Luvdisc
 
Pinkie pie:  
Since she just wants any Pokemon she would keep her starter and she will probably catch the most common pokemon out there:
 
Bulbasaur  
Ratatta  
Pidgey  
She will cheat her game to get Pokemon like  
Missingno  
Mew  
Mewtwo
 
Spike:  
Dragonite  
Kingdra  
Altaria  
Rayquaza  
Garchomp  
Haxorus

>dragons  
A sound idea.

@RIG  
That’s future Spike’s problem.

@Jayswing103  

Perfect team for Spike: Dragonair, Salamence, Garchomp, Haxorous, Druddigon, and Hydregion

@LV-04  
nope, Rarity = the female and pony version of this guy  

@LV-04  
Actually, pre-Gen 5, Rarity would be a Contest-fag.

Rarity = What the pokemon animators think girls are.
 
I prefer to never have status moves, Instead having attacks for multiple types.

Well, on the one hand, Spike is going to end up with a totally boss team. But on the other, his starter is freaking Magikarp.

I’m a Twilight, but I draw the line at IV/EV training. I’m not going to try to manipulate the underlying metamechanics of the game for my own benefit. Putting that much effort into a video game just seems kind of sad.  
And yes, I’m profoundly aware of the irony.

@Zennistrad: What? No Ninetails? S/he was beautiful before it was cool

Spike = Lance

Dragonite, Tyranatar, Metagross, Aggron, Garchomp, Hydreggion Ultimate team.

@Zennistrad
 
Wouldn’t Purugly be a closer match to Opal?

Actually, BP, you forgot Pidgeot.

I would pay to see ponies train pokémon. I wanna travel with them! It would be so much fun!! I’ll bring my Latios, my registeel, my flygon…

Venusaur, Blastoise, Charizard, Pikachu Butterfree and Kingler will destroy any team ever.
 
(those were ash’s first 6 if you exclude raticate right?)

Also, all of Rarity’s Pokemon except Milotic know the move “Power Gem.”

Rarity’s Team:
 

Hey, my Rosalia was fucking fabulous. You don’t badmouth her.

@RIG  
This.

Rarity=Ruby