Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Come Celebrate Animation, Old and New!

Derpibooru costs over $25 a day to operate - help support us financially!

Description:

safe1727384 artist:maxressor96 lyra heartstrings29860 princess celestia95840 sci-twi24655 sunset shimmer63863 twilight sparkle303150 alicorn228564 pony987659 unicorn332490 fanfic:anthropology100 3d78153 archaeology33 book33939 computer6265 drink4966 evening514 female1381724 flag3970 hair bun3423 laptop computer2343 macbook56 magic74292 mare491189 ponified41593 ponified humanized pony75 royal guard7929 self ponidox8234 source filmmaker47374 stargate79 telekinesis28213 tent949 toolbox145 twilight sparkle (alicorn)124928 twolight1181 unicorn sci-twi730

Comments

Syntax quick reference: *bold* _italic_ [spoiler]hide text[/spoiler] @code@ +underline+ -strike- ^sup^ ~sub~
AllHailPrincessLuna

@youregoingtoloveme
To be fair, I don't even remember what the premiere was about — and that's saying a lot.
Actually the whole season felt a lot like fanfiction. There was a lot of mediocrity, few bad episodes and one gem.
Actually, my favourite episode was the one with alternative timeline and that's never good.
Even the ending, though it wrapped up most of plots, felt bad. It was epic and the threat was resolved in last seconds, but landing Atlantis in San Francisco? ZPM modules from parallel dimensions?
I was 19 when it came out and even then I found it ridiculous.

Sg:U tried to make series fresh, but leaned too much on BSG. Unfortunately Sci-Fi realized that when they were in the middle of second season of already cancelled show…
youregoingtoloveme

***warning: if you don't care about Stargate, give this tl;dr comment a pass***
@AllHailPrincessLuna
Was it just me, though? I felt that the drop in writing quality in "Search and Rescue" was unbelievably steep. Every character's dialogue was written intelligently and with that character's unique personality in mind — up to that point. Had a drinking game started where a shot was taken everytime someone stated the obvious for exposition purposes, I would have passed out in ten minutes. Even Michael, who started out as a very interesting rogue nemesis of the Atlantis team, started speaking like a stereotypical cartoon villain of the week. Sam's replacement felt sloppy, Ronon was little more than a bobblehead doll, Rodney was unscientific, Col. Caldwell was even more wooden than usual, and Dr.Keller sounded as though she had barely received a lesson in first aid.

Did they let a fanfic author write the dialogue for this episode? I lost count of how many bland, cheesy, cookie cutter four or five word long sentences the actors rattled off.

After four solid seasons of surpassing my expectations with entertaining and engaging personalities combined with exciting storytelling, I found this whole episode to be highly offensive and if someone on the show staff could give the script for Search and Rescue a green light, they must have lowered their standards and stopped caring. So I stopped caring, too. I'm 44. I've never ragequit a show in my life until now. I'll admit that those episode premises you mention sound fun but I would have preferred to have seen them in an earlier season when there was still some semblance of quality control.
AllHailPrincessLuna

@youregoingtoloveme
Then you missed pseudo-CSI, alternative timeline episode in which Sheppard is a failed cop living in a trailer in LV, mostly drinking and listening to Johny Cash. As stupid as it sounds, I enjoyed it.

And rogue Asgards in Power Armours, that too was a thing
Sejen

Sunset: "Apparently this inscription we uncovered records what the first travelers said on arrival."
Celestia: "Which was?"
*Sunset: "'Ponies?? No… Just… no… If anyone asks, we found nothing! Lets get back to Destiny… I'd prefer being lost in space…'"
AllHailPrincessLuna

@Background Pony #F402
they are building a portal for humans and ponies traveling through equestria and the human world in its original form without having to no longer use the mirror and are no longer becoming a ponies to humans or humans to becoming a the ponies
They're not building it, they're excavating it.

That said, it's a wonder they found complete DHD — these things are rare!
Background Pony #70FA
they are building a portal for humans and ponies traveling through equestria and the human world in its original form without having to no longer use the mirror and are no longer becoming a ponies to humans or humans to becoming a the ponies