Why do you like Quagmire’s Dad? What is it that resonates with you?
Anonymous
I’d always liked Quagmire’s Dad even before I realized I was trans. I saw it at a time where I didn’t know much about trans people and the resources I had (namely bitchy anons screaming at me) weren’t giving me the information I needed. This episode gave me that information. Quagmire’s Dad explicitly answers every single invasive question that trans people get asked.
But then when I was one of those people and knew it, I started experiencing the exact same things that Ida goes through in that episode.
Being told I was just a “chemically imbalanced crossdresser” and that my identity was “too much” for my friends and family to handle, and being interrogated about what I was going to do about what’s in my pants and being told I was lying because I didn’t fit their perfect mold of a trans person and having to deal with people insisting that I convince them that I wasn’t inferior to them…
That made me think about the episode of Family Guy where a trans woman is explicitly put through all of that and answers those questions FOR the dipshit audience so that I and others like me don’t have to. MacFarlane knew what I was going through. He knew how it felt to have your very person-hood interrogated and for others to prioritize their feelings over your happiness.
There’s a bit toward the middle and the end of the episode where Quagmire tries pulling the whole “This is hard for me to adjust to” schtick and Ida completely shuts it down. She (in calmer words than I ever would) says “No. This is my life. You don’t get a choice in the matter. I don’t care how hard it is for you, you WILL adjust to it.” Some people actually complained that Ida didn’t consider her son’s feelings in all of this, like this jackass on the TVTropes page.
image
There’s more crap like this talking about how Quagmire is the only “relatable” character in the episode and how Ida is being inconsiderate. It’s hilarious how much this shit goes over their heads.
The fact of the matter is, MacFarlane wrote Ida this way because he knows that Ida is under no obligation to consider Quagmire’s feelings about it. People who behave this way in real life have to suck it up. And Quagmire is explicitly told to suck it up.
That stuck with me, especially when my father tried pulling that stunt.
Family Guy is the only show to explicitly say “No, you don’t owe anybody an explanation for your identity. You are not the problem here, they are.”
I call Seth MacFarlane “the most woke TV Producer” as a joke at just how two-faced much of Hollywood is. With how many producers claim to support LGBT people, only to either wait until the last second to give them representation, give them representation and then immediately kill the characters, or do something like Garnet where the LGBT characters are hidden from view most of the time, MacFarlane is the only one who has openly, aggressively and proudly vocalized his support for LGBT rights. He’s always balanced out his crude humor by putting his money where his mouth is.
I will gladly take genuine support peppered with frat boy humor over the disingenuous bullshit that many other producers give.
~Lily
to see the image I recommend clicking on the link to see what the image said but for those that don’t want to click on the link here is what the image is.
Unintentionally Unsympathetic: As pointed out by Jem Ida is this. The episode was meant to be a sympathetic portrayal of the transgendered yet despite the fact that Ida had the advantage of thinking about this for years she never thought about how it would affect her son. She never told her son who idolizes her about her intentions to become a woman. She gave him no time to adjust, yet she scolded him for not taking it well right off the bat while ignoring the fact that Peter and Lois were openly mocking her. And then she reveals that she didn’t even consider how he’d take it to begin with.
Now that I think about it isn’t Ida still treated like a joke in Family Guy?