Anyways, finally got around to starting
Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru aka Oregairu aka
My Teenage Romcom SNAFU.
The show starts with the usual “I’m too mature for high school” speech a lot of these back-row-seat protags make, and it’s immediately ripped apart by an actual adult. Just beautiful.
I really enjoyed this early takedown of an angsty Nice Guy(tm), but I also appreciate that they framed his cynicism as a result of his life’s circumstances. Makes him more believable and a bit more sympathetic.
The core three’s first interactions were really sharp, cutting through ideas that other shows might take entire episodes to unwrap. And I like the begrudging mutual respect they have for each other, sharing their personal struggles so the others might learn from them. They’re not exactly friends yet, but they understand why their teacher put them in this club; they might be good for each other.
I like characters who are inwardly focused and self-analyzing, and I’m a huge sucker for stories about how we’re all damaged in different ways. Hachiman and Yukino are both reasonable people, but his emotional immaturity causes him to form a superiority complex, while her insularity and inexperience with dealing with others causes her to project impossible standards onto others. Really compelling dynamic, and it could be fun watching them fuck up and learn from their mistakes.
Nitpicks: Yukino’s VA clearly out-acts Hachiman’s in some spots which took away from their back-and-forth a bit, and Yui is literally introduced tits-first. But it’s alright. Yukino’s intro was very reminiscent of
Hyouka and thought that was a damn high star for a romcom to aiming for, but this is a really good start.