11: To be fair, it was her or Pinkie, and admittedly is more a case of apathy over active dislike. But her lacking in stand out aspects doesn't do her favors to me, I'd rather have them standing out from the crowd.
10: He and his sister have similar problems of not being too interesting.
9: Became brony flagship for some minor gag.
8: I kinda wish they play along with the human gimmick, but became pure shipping fodder instead.
7: I mean, is the shipping fodder of 8. It really kills the interest.
6: Meh, I like neither. A stoic dullard nonetheless. And her sister is just painfully meek.
5: I hate her. I didn't put her higher on the list only because I must also factorize how others like her to make this and she's admittedly somewhat divisive here and there for some.
4: She's a ditz, that's all her gimmick. Also tacos. I hate tacos.
3: Starts being too cowardly for my taste. And after getting some backbone, she actually loses relevance so it feels just kinda there.
2: Ugh, couldn't just make her an evil mad scientist instead of a meek one in the third and fourth movie? Why? She's supposed to be Twilight fucking Sparkle, the snarky smartass dangit.
1: Really, never liked her, and a lot of the time her incompetence in some aspects overstretched the disbelief for me.