AC97
"@DarkyBoode32":/forums/pony/topics/scootaloo-being-disabled?post_id=4901158#post_4901158
[bq]and my argument on this is now over with.[/bq]
...unironically using the word "brainwashed" to describe what Scootaloo was doing is just... well... huh.
Lightning Dust did *_nothing_* to manipulate Scootaloo's inherent feelings about "will I fly," Rainbow Dash drew Scootaloo's ire by being "unintentionally insensitive.":https://youtu.be/79oz_ClLmf8
[bq]*Rainbow Dash*: Uh... Heh. Sorry that was a little... intense. I just wanna make sure you don't get hurt. That way, you can follow in my hoofsteps. Heh. Everypony's dream, right?
*Scootaloo*: More like "follow your wingflaps".
*Rainbow Dash*: Same difference.
*Scootaloo*: [sarcastically] Thanks, super-talented flyer, for clearing up what _I_ should do.[/bq]
If you have a counterargument _showing_ something Lightning Dust said about Scootaloo flightlessness, other than baseless assertions, go right ahead and show me.
I don't see why merely being frustrated with Rainbow Dash would affect that thought process, if that's the reasoning. I don't think her sense of self is that fragile.
[bq]I quote from Flight To The Finish: “What if my wings never grow? What if I never fly?” -Scootaloo
Scootaloo was in the right mindset in that episode but wasn’t when she said the quote you replied with.[/bq]
...You're quoting *_S4_* Scootaloo, which is a _long time_ for her mind on the matter to change from unsurety (not even _confidence_ that she would, back in S4), to surety in S8, and while Sweetie Belle has gone from learning tosimply levitate objects in S4, to being able to cast "Accelero":/images/1714131 in S8, Scootaloo has made no such progress, to the point that it's prominent, and it's especially notable when _other pegasi_ around her age can fly, in contrast to how learning magic seems to generally be a less inherent ability for unicorns than flying is for pegasi.
Like it or not, Scootaloo _most likely_ came to that conclusion by S8 on her own, that it wouldn't happen, to argue otherwise is infantilizing her, and GUIHTD reinforced that (unless you're grasping for straws; she was physically aged up magically, and to take it any other way than face value is unfounded headcanon... also, if you "_listen_ to their voices during that episode,":https://youtu.be/2_lD4rAqCPg you'll notice they're _not artificially pitched up_, when they're aged up, all three of them, so that earlier argument is _invalid_, about how _"her voice was the same, so the same argument could be said about her wings"_), as did The Last Problem (which did happen, contrary to your delusions), and a character's "normal" can change, as was the whole _point_ of, for one episode of many, Forever Filly.
And even if Scootaloo _did_ ever fly under her own power, no glider or something to offset her issues (she'd make good speed with one of those, with her propulsion strength), it'd be really, _really_ unlikely for her to be anything other than below-average, if not in the bottom ten percentile. I just don't see any other way around it.
There's probably a symbolic reason Scootaloo's "associated":/images/1218526 with "chickens":/images/1218533
[bq]and my argument on this is now over with.[/bq]
...unironically using the word "brainwashed" to describe what Scootaloo was doing is just... well... huh.
Lightning Dust did *_nothing_* to manipulate Scootaloo's inherent feelings about "will I fly," Rainbow Dash drew Scootaloo's ire by being "unintentionally insensitive.":https://youtu.be/79oz_ClLmf8
[bq]*Rainbow Dash*: Uh... Heh. Sorry that was a little... intense. I just wanna make sure you don't get hurt. That way, you can follow in my hoofsteps. Heh. Everypony's dream, right?
*Scootaloo*: More like "follow your wingflaps".
*Rainbow Dash*: Same difference.
*Scootaloo*: [sarcastically] Thanks, super-talented flyer, for clearing up what _I_ should do.[/bq]
If you have a counterargument _showing_ something Lightning Dust said about Scootaloo flightlessness, other than baseless assertions, go right ahead and show me.
I don't see why merely being frustrated with Rainbow Dash would affect that thought process, if that's the reasoning. I don't think her sense of self is that fragile.
[bq]I quote from Flight To The Finish: “What if my wings never grow? What if I never fly?” -Scootaloo
Scootaloo was in the right mindset in that episode but wasn’t when she said the quote you replied with.[/bq]
...You're quoting *_S4_* Scootaloo, which is a _long time_ for her mind on the matter to change from unsurety (not even _confidence_ that she would, back in S4), to surety in S8, and while Sweetie Belle has gone from learning to
Like it or not, Scootaloo _most likely_ came to that conclusion by S8 on her own, that it wouldn't happen, to argue otherwise is infantilizing her, and GUIHTD reinforced that (unless you're grasping for straws; she was physically aged up magically, and to take it any other way than face value is unfounded headcanon... also, if you "_listen_ to their voices during that episode,":https://youtu.be/2_lD4rAqCPg you'll notice they're _not artificially pitched up_, when they're aged up, all three of them, so that earlier argument is _invalid_, about how _"her voice was the same, so the same argument could be said about her wings"_), as did The Last Problem (which did happen, contrary to your delusions), and a character's "normal" can change, as was the whole _point_ of, for one episode of many, Forever Filly.
And even if Scootaloo _did_ ever fly under her own power, no glider or something to offset her issues (she'd make good speed with one of those, with her propulsion strength), it'd be really, _really_ unlikely for her to be anything other than below-average, if not in the bottom ten percentile. I just don't see any other way around it.
There's probably a symbolic reason Scootaloo's "associated":/images/1218526 with "chickens":/images/1218533