MLP G5 Discussion and Speculation Thread
Dustcan 
Dogs
My biggest gripe about C5 is that it more or less shot down Alphabittle being Izzy’s surrogate father. But that was just some headcanon, so not really an issue on the show’s end.
Crackpot Quackpot 
Erratically Sane
@GoodVibesGorgeous
Well guess they didn’t feel like using it
Well guess they didn’t feel like using it
@Background Pony #CC3D
It wasn’t tropical at first though
It wasn’t tropical at first though
@Background Pony #CC3D
My childhood is certainly foggy but I do remember the more eventful parts.
My childhood is certainly foggy but I do remember the more eventful parts.
The Moondancer information is strange, there were supposed to be five generations between her and Elder Flower, but in a TYT episode it says ten generations, and the blanket was mentioned in MYM. We know that ponies can grow old, in special cases over a hundred years old or more. Elder Flower may have lived much longer than normal and she talked about a marriage with possibly changelings there, which then means that changelings were alive in her lifetime. It is possible that it is a different Moondancer.
I was gonna leave that alone but I can’t believe you’re agreeing with him. Maybe the Shining Armor is a different Shining Armor, maybe there’s a diva Rainbow Dash, hell even Sunset Shimmer might be stranded in Equestria from the EG universe.
Background Pony #0D99
What will happen to MYM after Chapter 6?
GoodVibesGorgeous
Grumpy and antisocial
@Background Pony #0D99
It’ll end, probably. Then, we’ll only have TYT… Or perhaps a new series is coming. We’ll find out soon!
It’ll end, probably. Then, we’ll only have TYT… Or perhaps a new series is coming. We’ll find out soon!
Background Pony #0D99
If TYT is the only G5 show left after MYM Chapter 6, then I’m done with G5.
Background Pony #13BA
@GoodVibesGorgeous
Creating a new 3D series under a new name won’t do much. Plus, it’d be costly to start a new one.
Creating a new 3D series under a new name won’t do much. Plus, it’d be costly to start a new one.
Background Pony #DFBF
@Background Pony #0D99
Tbf, considering how costly it is to use cgi, it’s expected that it would end.
Tbf, considering how costly it is to use cgi, it’s expected that it would end.
@Background Pony #13BA
True.
True.
Background Pony #545C
It’s kinda odd that Alpha almost reminds me of gnomes with his beard. Like the dude from the “Gnomeo and Juliet” movie
Crackpot Quackpot
Erratically Sane
Funny headcanon I had, all the other races actually live near the ponies in secret. Why we don’t see them? They’re standing absolutely still.
GoodVibesGorgeous
Grumpy and antisocial
@Background Pony #13BA
I’ve never said it would be another 3D series… It could be a 2D one, like TYT. But with longer and more adventure-focused episodes.
I’ve never said it would be another 3D series… It could be a 2D one, like TYT. But with longer and more adventure-focused episodes.
Background Pony #545C
Mane Smelody was a fun episode.
The faces she made and her reactions were funny!. It was ironic that Jazz wouldn’t want to be the bitt of a joke without knowing. Yet she actually is with the fandom because her lack of ears
MYM Jazz! She’s so cute and she appeared in the episode!
Favourite episode was Mane Smelody. Least favourite was the last episode
Crackpot Quackpot
Erratically Sane
Blind reaction to the final episode
-Is this their second Nightmare Night? What has Opaline been doing?
-He found it! Mission accomplished!
-Since Luna came back, Misty
-That wasn’t her? Also I guess she didn’t know that holiday was made after Luna turned evil. Or that she turned evil to begin with
-Senor Butterscotch has been discarded :(
-Pipp was a better host yeah?
-Appuls!
-There’s a 4th one?
-There can only be one arch nemesis!
-If you dare!
-Too bad they forgot her
-Hitch never breaks promises
-Hah! In your face! You succeeded but still failed! Though, it’s still Twilight’s mistake in leaving her as a mere memory.
-Did she just…?
-Sprout as himself
-BAAAAAALLLD!!!!!
-Now Those are some dragons!
-Is this their second Nightmare Night? What has Opaline been doing?
-He found it! Mission accomplished!
-Since Luna came back, Misty
-That wasn’t her? Also I guess she didn’t know that holiday was made after Luna turned evil. Or that she turned evil to begin with
-Senor Butterscotch has been discarded :(
-Pipp was a better host yeah?
-Appuls!
-There’s a 4th one?
-There can only be one arch nemesis!
-If you dare!
-Too bad they forgot her
-Hitch never breaks promises
-Hah! In your face! You succeeded but still failed! Though, it’s still Twilight’s mistake in leaving her as a mere memory.
-Did she just…?
-Sprout as himself
-BAAAAAALLLD!!!!!
-Now Those are some dragons!
Background Pony #DFBF
@GoodVibesGorgeous
I doubt that they’ll want two 2D series, made by the same studio. Plus, even then, they’ll likely put it on netflix.
I doubt that they’ll want two 2D series, made by the same studio. Plus, even then, they’ll likely put it on netflix.
Background Pony #F47E
@Background Pony #CC3D
I don’t think TYT is canon yet. TYT and MYM contradict eatch other quite often. But after MYM’s end then I think it will be considered canon. I mean the adventures after MYM.
I don’t think TYT is canon yet. TYT and MYM contradict eatch other quite often. But after MYM’s end then I think it will be considered canon. I mean the adventures after MYM.
Background Pony #B010
So secrets of starlight up next
PuffyDearlySmith 
Fan of both G4 and G5
Watching “Mane Smelody”, you’d figure Pipp would try to lessen the strength of the flower’s stink before making it into hoof polish.
WestRail642fan 
Banned from 3 Discords
@PuffyDearlySmith
she had gotten use to the smell and thought it disappeared during the process to make it into polish
she had gotten use to the smell and thought it disappeared during the process to make it into polish
PuffyDearlySmith
Fan of both G4 and G5
Yeah, her and Jazz both. Fortunately Izzy saved the day by bringing some much nicer smelling flowers to mix into the polish. Also this is the second episode I’ve Sprout socializing with the town ponies(The first being the Nightmare Night episode, I’ve been watching these in reverse). That would mean everypony for the most part has moved past his take over of the town.
PuffyDearlySmith
Fan of both G4 and G5
Dunno, I downloaded the first and last episodes first and just started from there.
Dragonpone 
Moderator
Badge Dragon
Scattered Ch. 5 thoughts
Sparky might be leaving soon \o/
Alphadad is still lame, but dammit I still smiled when they hugged
G3 Breezies > G5 Breezies > G4 Breezies
For the love of Celestia, someone keep Pipp away from Bridlewood
Good on Moondancer’s sister for getting laid, clearly Moondancer herself wasn’t going to make it happen
Maybe I’ve just gotten used to her ugliness, but I swear Opaline (and some others) have had colors/lighting improved over time.
Chapter ended kinda abruptly?
I find it interesting people seem to hold Chapter 4 higher, cause this is easily the best one so far, imo. I like, actually enjoyed it. It’ll suck if MYM ends when it feels like it’s genuinely improving.
Andyxdr
Glowin' up!
@Dragonpone
Can I ask why you want Pipp away from Bridlewood? Is it because it doesn’t look like the right place for her or does she screw things up there or something else?
Can I ask why you want Pipp away from Bridlewood? Is it because it doesn’t look like the right place for her or does she screw things up there or something else?
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Help fund the $15 daily operational cost of Derpibooru - support us financially!