> And that’s exactly why the Sequel Trilogy is a failure at being Star Wars story.
Sure. You know SW so I take your word for it.
> And I might argue not a good story at all.
This is where I disagree. Any story can be made into a good story. Just gotta know what strings to pull.
The premise of creative piece does not automatically tell the value
if said piece.
You can always botch an underdog story, similarly you can make inexplicably OP-character story bearable or even alright.