The original Jump the Shark website. Sadly, it’s no longer the same as it was since 2009, and it’s successor
Bone the Fish isn’t as funny as the original site.
Also, the GameFAQs forums were really small. I was one of the eariler members joining in early 2000 ant there only at most 200 people on there. I even started a game on the Random Insanity board called the Wheel of Torture which was very popular, and I’ve since refined it over the years. I wonder if the imageboards ever caught on to it…