So, here’s a bit of a bigger update regarding the status of the collab, as well as some of my thoughts about what it should be:
Anyone who’s seen the 2019 collab (
>>1945331), or even the 2018 collab (
>>1623600) will realize that characters were largely arranged by color, with a lot of regard to artistic style. Everything flowed together really nicely, each image looked very nice next to every image surrounding it. Originally, I was taking the same approach to the 2020 collab - I’d place a character, and then search through every remaining submission looking for the one that looks the best next to the one I just placed.
This is why it’s been going so slow - sometimes it’d take me 5-10 (sometimes 15) minutes to find a single image to add to the collab. I’d find one that looks like it may fit, add it, then realize it doesn’t look quite as good with the character in the row before it, so I have to remove it and go looking for another character. This was especially tricky with characters/groups in odd poses, or a character holding something that needed to be shown off (like a plushie). The process I was using trying to keep everything nice and smooth was causing things to progress extremely slowly.
Even worse - I zoomed out and looked at what I had so far overall, and quite frankly - it looked so fucking boring. It was just a few hundred OCs arranged in neat, even lines, sorted by colors. It looked nice, but it felt more like like a class photo than a fun event:
I wasn’t excited by what I was seeing. It didn’t feel like a Derpibooru collab. It didn’t reflect my vision on what a Derpibooru collab should be, nor my feelings on what the Derpibooru community is. Simply put - it wasn’t fun.
So I deleted over half of it.
Then I grabbed around thirty random submissions without regard to color, art style, etc and imported them all into the collab’s main PSD all at once. I scaled them all to be the same size, then just arranged them into a neat little blob around what was left. No regards to consistency, no neat organized even lines, nothing. Just thirty random ponies arranged in a way that looked nice. Then I grabbed another thirty and did it again. And again. And again.
After doing that a few times, the collab started taking a new shape. It looks a bit more chaotic than previous collabs, and a bit more disorganized. But in turn, it looks absolutely amazing. It looks like a snapshot of an actual community. It’s fun, it’s exciting, it’s inclusive, it looks great. And while I’m only just under a third of the way done, I think with this new approach I’m taking, it’s gonna be the best one yet. I’m definitely magnitudes more excited about what I’m looking at now than what I was looking at last night.
And yes - I did say “just under a third of the way done”. After deleting over half the collab, I went from ~330 characters to only 156. But this new approach I am taking is so fast that the current count is exactly 447 characters. In the past twenty four hours, I managed to make almost the same amount of progress that I made in the three weeks prior, but the results are so much better.
Overall, I feel like the approach I took to the 2019 collab just wasn’t all that great. At a minimum, it doesn’t scale well. I feel I was making a huge mistake trying to apply the same approach to the 2020 collab, but luckily I caught myself in time and things are looking much better now.
So yeah, that’s the status. It’s going great, and I’m now officially excited.