Applejack: Ah don’t know. There was one time she got bitten by a fruit bat, but Ah doubt it’s because of that.
=
After seeing Applejack wearing Granny Smith’s scarf, some folks jumped to the conclusion that Granny Smith has passed away. By that logic, if I wore my brother’s hat, that means my brother has died.
“My logic is undeniable.”
Others have already pointed out why this logic doesn’t work. But if Granny Smith was still alive, don’t you think we would’ve seen her along with Big Mac, Sugar Belle, and their kid at Sweet Apple Acres during the song?
Now, could Granny Smith still be alive? Maybe. Maybe’s she’s still around, but we just didn’t see her onscreen. But it’s not unlikely that she passed away, given how much time has passed since Twilight’s coronation.
A fairly long time has passed since the coronation, if she’s alive, she must be like 140 yrs old
Granny Smith should’ve died on season 2, it wouldn’t surprise me if she’s immortal at this point.