@MightyShockwave  
@Filliest filly  
Gatta disagree, I prefer their show designs. The comic designs are boring, and generic, and basically just look like 90% of every other pony character.

@Prometheus labs CEO  
And I just realized that the green one is aunt holiday and not another auntie lofty

Seems like aunt holiday may have a bit of face blindnes

@MightyShockwave  
Ahhhh, I had wondered about that since they showed up in the comics first.  
Kinda makes me worry about, what kind of design they would give Trixie’s mom in the show since, she showed up in the comics first too…

@MightyShockwave
 
I mean, show!Holiday looks good too, but comic!Lofty is better - the show version looks like Zesty Gourmand’s cousin or something.

@mjangelvortex  
That makes sense

@Darth Shy  
Same to be honest. But I’m leaning a bit more towards the show designs a bit more. The comic version of Auntie Lofty made it seem like she was the one biologically related to Scootaloo, even though she’s not. Likewise their comic designs reminded me a bit too much of Bon Bon and Granny Smith.
 
With the show design, it’s a bit more obvious that Aunt Holiday is the one biologically related to Scootaloo. I also like that the two of them have different body types (I’m quite fond of chubby ponies so of the four designs DHX’s version of Holiday is my favorite).

Ha.

I’m reminded of the plot to “The Visit”.

@Background Pony #43F2  
pretty much the comics are their own separate canon

Lol, I’m still kinda split on which designs I prefer

No witnesses!  
Get rid of them.

@Background Pony #43F2  
The writers don’t design the characters

When Generation Five begins, they should have the show writers and comic writers coordinate more so that they could avoid continuity issues.

I always liked more the comic design for the lesbian aunts

@MightyShockwave  
Holiday looks like a copy-paste young granny Smith.

There’s something very Frasier about this

@Background Pony #CF6B
 
The ponies in the closet are the comic portrayals of Auntie Lofty and Aunt Holiday. They were the first, and in my eyes, superior designs.

I don’t get it???