Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Champions of Equestria

Derpibooru costs over $25 a day to operate - help support us financially!

Description:

safe1704376 artist:animesoul55 angel bunny9827 apple bloom49437 applejack169712 big macintosh28233 daring do6410 discord30939 flash magnus830 fluttershy212420 granny smith5344 king sombra13872 lord tirek5292 maud pie12448 meadowbrook830 mistmane771 pharynx1004 pinkie pie216016 princess cadance32424 princess celestia94936 princess ember6500 princess flurry heart7253 princess luna99055 queen chrysalis34759 rainbow dash233710 rarity181651 rockhoof1143 scootaloo51218 shining armor23125 somnambula1913 spike78713 star swirl the bearded2019 starlight glimmer48595 sunburst6747 sweetie belle48989 thorax4329 trixie67418 twilight sparkle300084 zecora9354 alicorn224092 centaur3394 changedling8350 changeling47520 draconequus11654 dragon56176 human154511 pony965631 unicorn322384 absurd resolution66204 alicorn humanization275 anime5532 changedling brothers258 clothes458887 confetti1917 cutie mark crusaders19010 discussion in the comments725 dress44431 elements of harmony2454 epic1364 equestria girls outfit2426 female1361201 final battle55 gala dress4567 good vs evil56 horned humanization6766 humanized99980 king thorax2887 male372006 mane seven6502 mane six31869 mare479570 party cannon1757 pillars of equestria287 pony coloring2717 prince pharynx734 stallion108528 tailed humanization3014 tired3127 twilight sparkle (alicorn)123568 wall of tags3057 winged humanization8686 wings106996

Comments

Syntax quick reference: *bold* _italic_ [spoiler]hide text[/spoiler] @code@ +underline+ -strike- ^sup^ ~sub~
DarkObsidian
Twinkling Balloon - Took part in the 2021 community collab.
Ten years of changes - Celebrated the 10th anniversary of MLP:FiM!
My Little Pony - 1992 Edition
Economist -

EAW Panzerfuchs
@Background Pony #5236

@Dsiak

@Background Pony #F208

Maybe we should talk about the sense and purpose of a spin-off. These are based and coexist at the same time as the original, but tell a different story and do not necessarily refer to the original.

Making Sunset appear in MLP would undermine some of its core attributes. She resembles very much to the character of Starlight Glimmer, therefore it is not necessary at all that Sunset appears in MLP. It would undermine the whole purpose of a spin-off. Especially because these are usually produced without using resources from the source. Or at least quite a few.

Making Sunset appear in MLP may make the hearts of many fanboys beat faster, but for purely economic reasons this is counterproductive. And if there's something Hasbro cares about, then please let's have some sales figures. And in these Sunset Shimmer does exist. Otherwise Hasbro would have spent a lot of money on nothing.

All I can do is shake my head at this kind of quibbling. It should be obvious to every viewer that Sunset exists but belongs to a different universe. Much like She-Ra. With the sirens these universes were connected, so it belongs to the canon, end, over & out. Other words about it are downright ridiculous. At least, in my opinion.
Background Pony #9D34
@genervt
That all happened in EqG. But even in that special she went to visit Twilight out of necessity, not because she wanted to or she was invited.

My point here is that the show ignores her existence and if she's canon than it shows Twilight doesn't care much about her.
Background Pony #9D34
@genervt
Yes but that's never implied in the show. In the show Twilight has no pictures of her, we never see the journal and she's never invited to any events. It heavily implies Twilight doesn't care much about her.
Background Pony #E696
If Equestria Girls is canon, then why don't they go and make a FiM episode about it? The Movie is quickly accepted as canon because there are enough episodes with characters saying and doing things that confirm the events of The Movie. Everything they're doing so far about EqG are just Tweeting stuffs and throwing a 30s cameo that doesn't mean much, then probably forgot about it, until FiM ends.

I really do want EqG to be canon, but what the writers are doing about the subject is… unsatisfying.

As I said, unless they outright confirm or deny EqG existence in FiM. There will still be skeptical people not agreeing Sunset is canon. We can keep our opinions. They won't change their mind.