Uploaded by Background Pony #F1D7
 2048x2048 PNG 2.22 MB
Interested in advertising on Derpibooru? Click here for information!
Sky Railroad Merch Shop!

Derpibooru costs over $25 a day to operate - help support us financially!

Description:

My main problem this season with just the premise alone. It literally contradicts the pilot episode!!!
That's not even including the character regression of the mane 6 (and Discord too) for plot convenience even more than usual previous seasons.

Image without captions
safe1658075 edit127786 edited screencap62265 screencap215992 princess celestia93079 spike77233 twilight sparkle294098 alicorn215132 dragon53483 pony922387 unicorn303733 friendship is magic2751 school daze2716 season 1574 season 8823 spoiler:s08761 adventure in the comments1273 animation error1992 drama3158 ethereal mane7416 female1321216 implied school of friendship5 male357102 mare458063 meme80746 op is a duck4365 ponyville5586 princess celestia's school for gifted unicorns57 school of friendship1211 twilight sparkle (alicorn)121045 unicorn twilight15999

Source:

not provided yet

Comments

Syntax quick reference: *bold* _italic_ [spoiler]hide text[/spoiler] @code@ +underline+ -strike- ^sup^ ~sub~
Background Pony #7C10
In season one Twilight's lack of understanding of friendship was a personal failing of hers that other people didn't have. She had to address it by moving out of her seclusion in her tower and go to a place where she'd have to be involved with people on a daily basis so she could gain what they already had.

Then we're told her overcoming this problem made her special and superior when she transforms into an alicorn even though she was trying attain something everyone else already had, not seeking something unique.

Then she moves into a new tower where she's be secluded even though the point of moving to the little town was to be around other people.

Then we're told she can teach others what she knows about friendship, even though it was something she had to learn for herself (Celestia doesn't and couldn't teach her).

The basic theme of the series has not been kept coherent. Pretty sloppy.
Background Pony #7C10
@Background Pony #AEBE
@PurpleWonderPower
This is not a continuity error. Celestia meant that you can't learn friendship from books and school alone.

How can you learn about friendship from books and school at all? She wasn't studying it in Canterlot before the story began; she was studying magic and mythology.
Background Pony #7C10
@CalypsoFantasy
They actually made Twilight look older between seven seasons. I love it.

I think that just came from her transformation at the end of season 3.
Dark Dash

You know, I never thought about this until now. In a way, its kind of interesting to think that letting Twilight's friendship with the rest of the mane six blossom naturally and have them take responsibility for their own trials and tribulations made them into the extraordinary group that they've become in Equestria. While attempting to teach the aspects of friendship to other in a systematic fashion led to young characters like Cozy Glow misconstruing the ideas of friendship to meet her own ends, as well as the young six who (while truly being friends) don't take the things being taught to them that seriously. In other words, letting it happen organically gave rise to a greater and deeper understanding for the mane six, while attempting to teach it through a system like a school has led to misunderstandings and apathy among those being taught.

I know this wasn't the intent of the writers and showrunners, but it's just something that comes to mind when thinking about the difference between these two opposing ideas that "Friendship can't be taught" in earlier seasons and "We should teach others about Friendship" in Season 8 onward