Stupid art. Both is honest

Sugarcoat and Apple Bloom: Wait, who even are you? And why are we talking to each other?

Technically both are being honest, it’s just one is being cruel and blunt rather than offering and constructive criticism

@The Smiling Pony  
She is, but that was an established fact. Her art critique isn’t the root of that.

@cdcdrr  
It does still mean she’s a cunt.

@Background Pony #F91B  
Or, you know, they just don’t have the time and patience to teach a little kid how to draw. Or even care about Apple Bloom or her art. That doesn’t mean Sugarcoat’s input is worthless, only that she’s not inclined to give it to just everyone who accosts her.

AJ’s method is better than Sugarcoat’s. End of story.

i’ve lost track of people who have accomplished things out of spite. what works is based on the person. sugarcoat isn’t good at sugarcoating things. which means if you do get praise out of her it will mean even more.
 
since her target was a kid that was to harsh, but if you know who she is you would expect a blunt level of rudeness.

@miados100  
Honesty isn’t all that matters; being a decent person matters to. In the example AJ also wants to help and encourage AB, while Sugar Coat is fucking damaged or is fucking damaged and wants to crush AB’s spirits.

but both of them are being honest. one is just being a polite honest while the other is a more…… blunt maybe? either way they are both honest about what they think.

Sugarcoat died that day…

@Background Pony #F91B  

 
Eh, not really into feeding their egos by asking them for help. If they had anything worthwhile to say, they’d have said it upfront. I’d just skip to the ignore and leave part then.

@Silver_lining  
It’s a waste of time to respond to someone like Sugarcoat that way. It’d be better to ask how it could be improved, and if they don’t give any actual criticism from then on, then ignore and leave them.

@Background Pony #F91B  

 
Is the point to argue, or to reach a satisfactory level of art?
 
See now, Sugarcoat here might think Bloom’s really bad at art (even though she’s a kid and hasn’t had the time it takes to practice “good” drawing) but art is subjective. Apple Bloom clearly meant to draw Zecora, and she conveyed that in her image by capturing Zecora’s basic characteristics. So Sugarcoat’s judging based on aesthetics rather than conveyance. At any rate, who cares if she thinks Apple Bloom’s bad at art? What purpose does that opinion serve? That she thinks Bloom shouldn’t even try even though it takes practice to be good at art in the first place? Sounds to me like Sugarcoat’s bad at critique.
 
Now AJ’s got the better mindset here, but it’s a bit vague as to how Bloom can improve. After all, what’s better to AJ may not be better to Bloom, you know? So the better mindset still is to ask whether she’s striving for more realism, with defined forms and believable anatomy, or more stylization, with more exaggerated proportions and simplified details.

@Silver_lining  
That’s risky. Even if they don’t put their money where their mouth is, you’re still gonna look like a bigger jackass who can’t come up with an argument.

@The Smiling Pony  

 
Dry a baby with newspaper? That’s nonsense. I suggest garnet paper (40 grit).

Sugarcoat!
 
Don’t bully her.

And you’re a horrible person, Sugarcoat >:(

@Background Pony #F91B  

 
@Four Tet  

 
It’s a ploy. Either they put their money where their mouth is and you gain some useful knowledge at the paltry cost of a little pride, making yourself better while turning their ego against them, or they back off and look foolish. That’s what they get for being rude.

Funny thing is, I can relate to the second panel.

@Background Pony #F91B  
Usually the last famous words before you get BTFO’d. Then you’re really hit in the gut!
 
Also, you know Sugarcoat would be throwing all kinds of art knowledge at you the moment you demand ask for pointers. Just like an art professor.

@The Smiling Pony  
Indeed, both Applejack and Sugar Coat are telling the truth, based on their perspectives, or that’s what I’m assuming. It’s just that Applejack’s giving good advice, while Sugar Coat, ironically, is just criticizing.

Why would Apple Bloom go all the way to the Crytal prep academy anyway?

@FanOfMostEverything  
The punchline is “terrible.” Get with the program.

@Silver_lining  
Going “Let’s see you do better!” isn’t much better…